Islanders’ Matthew Schaefer Becomes Second-Youngest Defenseman With NHL Hat Trick in 5-1 Win Over Blue Jackets

Matthew Schaefer scored three times on Tuesday night, becoming the second-youngest defenseman in NHL history to record a hat trick as the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1.

Only Hall of Famer Phil Housley, at 18 years, 320 days, was younger than Schaefer’s 19 years, 73 days when he reached the mark, the Associated Press reported. Schaefer also joined Housley as the only defensemen to score 30 goals before turning 20.

“You look at this roster, I mean, we can win any game,” center Mathew Barzal said after the win.

“I think with the coaching that we have, and Sorokin and Schaefer, just two of the best hockey players in the world on the ice, and a deep forward group — I mean, you look at our forward group, I think every line right now is moving well. So, I really like where this is headed.”

The Islanders have won three straight after a four-game skid. Ilya Sorokin stopped 28 shots, while Cam Talbot made 36 saves for Columbus, which lost its fifth game and seventh in nine.

Schaefer opened the scoring 1:34 into the second period. He struck again at 7:01 of the third, shoveling a backhand into an open net off a Ryan Pulock rebound after the Blue Jackets challenged for goaltender interference; the call on the ice was confirmed.

Anthony DeAngelo made it 4-1 at 11:52, roofing a backhand over Talbot’s blocker off a Barzal drop pass. Schaefer capped the night with an empty-netter at 16:08 for his ninth goal of the season.

New York Islanders' Matthew Schaefer (48) smiles as he celebrates with teammates after scoring a goal for his first career
Photo: tsn.ca

Zach Werenski spoiled Sorokin’s shutout bid 1:12 into the third. Anthony Duclair added a goal and an assist for New York.

Schaefer now has six career multi-goal games, passing Housley for the most by a teenage defenseman in league history. His 17 multi-point games are tied with Ray Bourque for second-most, trailing only Housley’s 34.

The Islanders visit the Winnipeg Jets on Thursday. The Blue Jackets play at the Chicago Blackhawks the same night.