Bridgeport police announced Wednesday that Douglas Jose Centeno-Vargas, 31, has been extradited from Nicaragua to face a murder charge in the October 2025 shooting death of 24-year-old Evelyn Rayo-Mairena, WKRC reported.
The case drew national attention because Rayo-Mairena’s 1-year-old daughter was found unharmed on a neighbor’s porch, still strapped in her car seat and wrapped in a bloody blanket, hours after her mother was shot in a car and dragged onto the street near the Black Rock Avenue home they shared.
Centeno-Vargas and Rayo-Mairena were from the same town in Nicaragua and knew each other as friends, Holtz told reporters. Police allege Centeno-Vargas shot Rayo-Mairena in the head while she sat in his car on Oct. 21, 2025, then pulled her body onto the pavement, where she was discovered and rushed to St. Vincent’s Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
After the killing, investigators say Centeno-Vargas was driven to John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York, boarded a flight to El Salvador, and continued on to Nicaragua — a nation that does not have an extradition treaty with the United States. He remained there for months, evading capture until Nicaraguan authorities detained him over the summer.
Holtz said the arrest followed extensive public pressure from Rayo-Mairena’s family. Nicaragua initially offered to prosecute Centeno-Vargas domestically, but the Connecticut State’s Attorney rejected that option, insisting he face charges in Bridgeport. The Nicaraguan government eventually relented and allowed U.S. Marshals and Interpol agents to repatriate him.

Centeno-Vargas now faces charges of murder, risk of injury to a minor, and tampering with physical evidence. He is being held on a $4 million bond and was scheduled for arraignment Wednesday. It was not immediately clear whether he had retained an attorney, People.com reported.
Bridgeport, Connecticut’s largest city with 148,654 residents in 2020, sits on Long Island Sound at the mouth of the Pequonnock River, 60 miles from Manhattan. Incorporated as a town in 1821 and a city in 1836, it was named for the bridges spanning the river that created a navigable port. Showman P. T. Barnum, a resident who housed his circus there in winter, served as mayor in 1871.
By 1905, Bridgeport had become the state’s chief manufacturing center, though industrial decline after World War II led to population loss and rising crime. The city is also known for several firsts: the world’s first mutual telephone exchange in 1877, the first Subway restaurant in 1965, and the invention of the American electric plug outlet in 1912.
“Yes, justice does exist,” Maria Carolina Rayo, the victim’s sister, said in Spanish at the press conference. “It won’t bring her back, but the person who committed this crime will pay for what he did and get the sentence he deserves.”
Maria Carolina Rayo, sister of Evelyn Rayo-Mairena
The child is now living with her father, police said. Bridgeport authorities credited cooperation among local detectives, the U.S. Marshals Service, Interpol, and the State Department for securing the extradition despite the lack of a formal treaty.
⚡ JUST IN 🇺🇸🇳🇮 Caught in Nicaragua: Suspect in Killing of Bridgeport Mom in Front of Her Baby Brought Back to Face Murder Charge A man accused of shooting a young Connecticut mother and leaving her 1-year-old daughter on a nearby porch has been tracked down in Nicaragua and…