Ryan Klund Argues Pre-Deciding Giving Turns Generosity Into Cheerful Habit

Ryan Klund argues in a post on LinkedIn that separating the decision to give from the moment of asking can transform generosity from a reluctant calculation into a cheerful habit.

Klund describes an experiment he and his wife began years ago after moving to the Milwaukee area. Driving down Miller Park Way, they frequently encountered people asking for money at traffic lights. Following a learned habit, Klund avoided eye contact and refused to give.

The couple hated how that felt, discussing the kind of people they wanted their future children and grandchildren to see them become. They withdrew $100 in five-dollar bills, placed the cash in the glove box, and decided in advance that every encounter would receive five dollars.

The money was already gone, at least in their minds, Klund writes. They were no longer deciding at each intersection whether they could afford five dollars or whether a specific situation justified the expense.

Instead of hoping the light would turn green before someone reached the car, they looked for opportunities to roll down the window. Klund recalls making U-turns after realizing they had passed someone and missed the chance to give. “It was fun,” he writes.

Klund connects the personal experiment to his work with generous families at NCF. He cites 2 Corinthians 9:7: “Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” He emphasizes the phrase “as he has decided in his heart,” arguing there is power in separating the decision to give from the decision of where to give.

“What if some of our generosity began with a decision made in advance?” Klund asks. “This belongs to God. I’m going to give it away. Then, instead of repeatedly asking ourselves whether we can afford to be generous, we get to ask a different question: Where is God inviting me to use it?”