Josh Hart played 23 minutes against Indiana on Friday and scored zero points, a stat line that crystallized the worst start of his ten-year career, NBA.com reported.
The Knicks are 8-6, and their preferred starting five — Jalen Brunson, Hart, Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby and Karl-Anthony Towns — is generating just 100.0 points per 100 possessions, more than five points worse than the league’s last-ranked offense in Utah, Hoops Habit found. Hart’s three-point percentage has plummeted from a career-best 41.3 percent last season to 29.5 percent through 14 games, while his overall field-goal percentage has dropped from 50.8 to 36.2, according to Yardbarker.
“Wish I could tell you,” Hart told reporters after the Pacers loss. “Don’t know. Right now I’m not in a good headspace, and I got to figure out how to improve that. And improve my play.”

Coach Mike Brown benched Hart for the entire fourth quarter and overtime in Toronto on Tuesday, the second straight game he sat the veteran in crunch time. Hart responded with five points on 1-of-4 shooting from deep in 26 minutes, but the Knicks still needed overtime to beat the Raptors.
“For me, this is a little harder because I’m trying to get the mental aspect right and the physical aspect right,” Hart said afterward. “I’m battling both of those things. I’m trying to give myself a little bit of grace with that.”
The body isn’t cooperating either
A calf injury cost Hart three weeks in September. He reaggravated a right ankle issue in training camp, then missed a game with illness. Daily Knicks said that since his first full season in 2023-24, only Brunson and Bridges have logged more total minutes than Hart — heavy mileage for a 31-year-old who turns 32 in March. One finger sits at a near 90-degree angle; surgery would likely end his season.
“There’s less chances at the rim,” Hart told Yahoo Sports on Friday. “I think it also affects Mikal and OG. Coach Mike Brown says Mikal is the best runner in the league. So if you have the best runner in the league and you’re not running, you’re wasting one of his talents.”
The Knicks rank dead last in pace at 95 possessions per game, a stylistic shift that suppresses transition opportunities for their most athletic wings.
Contract cloud hangs over the huddle
The Knicks suspended extension talks with Hart and Towns in October, opting to revisit negotiations later in the season. Owner James Dolan has drawn a hard line against the second apron, letting Isaiah Robinson walk to Boston rather than pay the luxury tax.
CBS Sports reported that the front office chose “to play hardball and use the championship as an opportunity to squeeze players for a discount” rather than lock up the core immediately.
“That’s the low-hanging fruit,” Hart said when asked if the contract situation weighed on him. “Some of those things are amplified because you’re in a contract year, essentially. It’s human nature for it to be in the back of your mind, but when you start focusing on those things, negative outcomes happen.”

Yardbarker noted the Knicks could let Hart walk or explore a trade deadline move, though his current production would limit the return. He holds a team option for 2026-27, making him an expiring asset if New York declines it.
Historical comparison highlights Bridges’ struggles and offensive collapse
Hoops Habit drew a parallel to the 2006-07 Miami Heat, who followed a title with a first-round exit amid a sluggish start. Bridges has compounded the problem: he took four games to hit his first three-pointer this season and is averaging a career-low in scoring. The Knicks’ offensive identity — built on spacing, cutting and transition — collapses when two primary wings can’t punish closeouts.
Brunson remains elite (26.6 points, 5.7 assists), but his efficiency has dipped to 43.6 percent from the field and just 55.8 percent at the rim, per CBS Sports. The gravity that once opened driving lanes for New York’s guards has evaporated.
Tuesday showed a pulse, not a cure
Hart’s body language shifted against Toronto: no slumped shoulders, no arguments with officials, immediate apologies to teammates after mistakes. In a 90-second-half burst he delivered a clutch basket, a hustle offensive rebound and a decisive kick-out for a teammate’s open look — “all of his hits,” as NBA.com described it. He finished with five points but played with the “joyful spirit” he said had been missing.
“Today, I think I had a little bit better of a spirit,” Hart said.

The Knicks host Philadelphia on Friday. Brown’s rotation decisions in crunch time will signal whether Tuesday was a turning point or a brief reprieve.
“When you’re in the middle of it, there’s not much that can really help. At the end of the day… today, I think I had a little bit better of a spirit.”
Hart was born in Silver Spring, Maryland, in 1995 and reached the rank of Eagle Scout in 2013. At Villanova, he won a national championship in 2016 and earned consensus first-team All-American honors as a senior.
Drafted by the Los Angeles Lakers in 2017, he was later traded for Anthony Davis to New Orleans and for CJ McCollum to Portland before joining the Knicks at the 2023 deadline. He now holds the franchise record for triple-doubles in a single season.
Disclaimer: The analytical insights and data provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.