Judge Dismisses Musk Election Bribery Lawsuit Over Lack of Standing

A Brown County judge has dismissed a civil lawsuit accusing Elon Musk of election bribery tied to the 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court race, ruling the plaintiffs lacked legal standing to bring the case.

Circuit Judge Marc Hammer signed the decision on November 18 and it was filed the following day, ending a challenge brought by the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign and two individual voters, Paul Gagliardi and Deborah Patel.

The lawsuit alleged Musk and his political operation, America PAC, violated state law by offering more than $1 to induce people to vote, pointing to a Green Bay rally where Musk handed two attendees $1 million checks described as awards “in appreciation for you taking the time to vote,” Wisconsin Examiner reported.

“Wisconsin voters understand that doling out millions of dollars to induce people to vote is wrong,”

Scott Thompson, staff counsel at Law Forward, told Wisconsin Examiner.

The dismissal marks the second time this year that legal action against Musk over the race has stalled. In August, a special prosecutor declined to file criminal charges after the Wisconsin Elections Commission referred complaints alleging bribery violations.

The standing barrier

Hammer wrote that the plaintiffs did not allege they were prevented from, burdened during, or affected in any way in casting their ballots. The voters’ argument that Musk had “undermined Wisconsin’s democracy” by his actions “is not a concrete enough injury to give rise to standing,” the judge wrote, according to WBAY.

Elon Musk Handing out a million dollar check replica in Wisconsin, Photo from FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul
Photo: wjfw.com

The Wisconsin Democracy Campaign claimed Musk’s actions forced the organization to spend more time and resources “ensuring elections are not tainted by corruption.” Hammer rejected that, too, writing the group did not say it was blocked “from carrying out its mission of election advocacy, just that it had to use more effort and resources to do so.”

“Mere disagreement or frustration with Defendants’ conduct is insufficient to confer standing,”

Hammer wrote in the order.

The rally and the petition

The lawsuit centered on a chain of events in March 2025. America PAC posted a “Petition in Opposition to Activist Judges” on March 20, offering registered Wisconsin voters $100 for signing and another $100 for each successful referral, an offer that expired on Election Day, April 1, according to the decision summarized by WBAY.

Musk announced on X on March 27 that he would speak at a Wisconsin event on March 30 and “hand over two checks for a million dollars each in appreciation for you taking the time to vote.” He later deleted that announcement and posted another limiting entrance to those who had signed the petition. At the Green Bay rally, Musk called two attendees on stage and handed each a $1 million check.

Judge Dismisses Musk Election Bribery Lawsuit Over Lack of Standing
Photo: wbay.com

Criminal referral goes nowhere

Earlier this year, the Wisconsin Elections Commission voted 5-1 to submit two complaints to the Brown County district attorney’s office alleging Musk violated the state law against election bribery. The case was referred to a special prosecutor, La Crosse County District Attorney Tim Gruenke.

Gruenke declined to file charges, concluding the accusation was premised on “a poorly worded statement” Musk made on X and subsequently corrected. He wrote that a jury would be unlikely to convict Musk, stating, “Nobody was paid anything of value for voting or promising to vote,” according to WBAY.

America PAC, a super PAC created by Elon Musk to support Donald Trump’s 2024 presidential campaign, became the largest source of out-of-state money in the Wisconsin Supreme Court race. By the end of March 2025, the PAC’s spending in the state had topped $18 million, funding a petition and giveaway program as well as door-to-door canvassing. Musk was the primary donor, with his contributions making up 91% of declared contributions as of December 2024.

Plaintiffs plan to continue legal fight

Thompson said the dismissal “is a setback, but by no means the end of the road,” adding that Law Forward will “press forward and continue to stand up for free and fair elections.”

The plaintiffs had sought a declaratory judgment on two counts of election bribery and one count of unlawful lottery, along with an order barring similar conduct in the future and damages. Attorneys for Musk, America PAC, and United States of America Inc. filed a notice of entry of final order on November 19.