KC Peaches Shuts Nassau Street Site After 15 Years as Wage Costs Jump 49% and Footfall Falls 36%

KC Peaches expected its Nassau Street cafe to ride the post-pandemic recovery; instead, the 15-year-old staple opposite Trinity College shut its doors on Monday, citing a 49% surge in wage costs and a 36% collapse in city-center footfall since Covid.

The closure notice, posted on the window and reported by Dublin Live, thanked customers for “15 wonderful years” and pointed to “rising operating costs” as the driver.

Founder Katie Cantwell told Newstalk that the arithmetic no longer works: minimum wage has climbed from €10.50 to €14.15 an hour since January 2022, and with statutory sick leave and other benefits layered on, total labor costs are up roughly half versus pre-Covid levels, the Irish Times reported. At the same time, cost of goods sold — ingredients Cantwell insists are high-quality — has jumped 40%.

“It has been tougher, and obviously there’s been a huge amount of new costs that have come into play,” Cantwell said. “You can’t — what do you do?”

Dublin Town lobby group data shows footfall in the city center remains down 36% since the pandemic, the Irish Times reported. Cantwell argued the government must prioritize residential development in the core rather than on the outskirts to restore the customer base hospitality businesses rely on. “We need to look at getting more dwellings in the city centre and forcing developments to build for our citizens,” she said.

KC Peaches Shuts Nassau Street Site After 15 Years as Wage Costs Jump 49% and Footfall Falls 36%
Photo: The Journal

Labor Costs up ~49% Since Pre-Covid

  • Labor costs up ~49% since pre-Covid (minimum wage €10.50 → €14.15/hr plus sick leave and benefits), per Cantwell in the Irish Times.
  • City-center footfall down 36% versus pre-pandemic levels, per Dublin Town data cited by the Irish Times.
  • Cost of goods sold up ~40% post-Covid, squeezing margins on a menu built around premium ingredients.

Cost Structure Breaks the Model

The Nassau Street lease had become a drag on the wider group. Cantwell described the decision as cutting off a limb to save the body: Peaches Brasserie on St Stephen’s Green and Proof Trattoria on Thomas Street are performing well, and the catering arm on Pearse Street is unaffected, the Journal reported.

The Dame Street location closed earlier this year, though Cantwell told Business Plus last month she hopes to reopen it with a new concept before Christmas.

“As a business owner, you have to look at what you’ve got, and when you’ve got these amazing opportunities that need your time and are doing so well, and then you’ve got this other business over here that is draining resources and not going in the right direction,” Cantwell said.

“You have to at some point say, okay, I’m going to essentially cut off the limb to focus on the rest of the body that’s doing really well.”

Footfall Gap Won’t Close Without Housing

Cantwell’s diagnosis goes beyond her own ledger. She lives in the city center and says the vibrancy is real — but the population isn’t. “I think young people would be so happy to be in the city centre if we can give them the opportunities by building more residences,” she told Newstalk.

Without a residential critical mass, the daytime economy reliant on office workers and students cannot sustain the rent and wage floor now baked into Dublin hospitality.

The Irish Times said that 2023 and 2024 were strong years post-Covid; the deterioration accelerated in 2025. That timeline aligns with the phased minimum-wage increases and the introduction of statutory sick pay, which took effect in 2023 and expanded in 2024.

Katie Cantwell, managing director of KC Peaches. Photograph: Aidan Crawley
Photo: The Irish Times

Sector-Wide Signal

KC Peaches is not an outlier. The Cedar Tree, Ireland’s first Lebanese restaurant, is also set to close, the Irish Times noted. Cantwell warned others on Nassau Street will follow unless footfall recovers or costs moderate. “In this industry, there’s just no way to make it work with the continual pressure,” she said.

The group’s remaining units — Peaches Brasserie, relaunched with breakfast, lunch, and dinner service, and Proof Trattoria in Dublin 8 — will absorb staff where possible, the Journal reported. The Nassau Street lease may be reassigned.

“It was a big call to make,” Cantwell said. “I think the landscape has changed considerably since Covid; we’ve been trying a number of different things.”

Seattle native Katie Cantwell founded KC Peaches in 2006 on Pearse Street with €300,000 and business partner Vincent Carroll, starting as a café split with a central production unit. The concept — whole foods made primarily with Irish ingredients, a self-serve buffet, good coffee and housemade pastries — expanded to Nassau Street in 2011 using only reinvested profits, followed by Dame Street and St Stephen’s Green in 2013.

A major catering contract early on stabilised the business, but the pandemic upended the corporate client base when offices emptied, forcing a pivot to platters and canapés and the closure of the Dame Street site this spring.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and market analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a certified financial professional before making investment decisions.