Kompas Questions Constitutional Basis for Three Vice Presidents Proposal

Kompas.com has questioned the constitutional reasoning behind a proposal by Regional Representative Council (DPD) Chairman Sultan Baktiar Najamudin to create three vice presidential posts based in Sumatra, Kalimantan, and Papua.

In an opinion piece published on November 23, the outlet argued the proposal confuses regional representation with the organization of executive power. The article acknowledged the rationale — that Indonesia’s vast territory cannot be effectively managed by a single vice president and that additional posts could ensure fairer development and better regional representation — as commendable. However, it said the intention to enhance attention to regional issues does not justify increasing constitutional posts.

Ketua DPD RI Usulkan Indonesia Punya 3 Wakil Presiden, Tuai Kontroversi — KOMPASTV

The piece cited Article 4 paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution, which states that the President is assisted by one vice president. It said this provision must be read alongside Article 4 paragraph (1) on presidential power, Article 6A paragraph (1) on the election of the President and Vice President as a pair, and Article 8 on presidential succession, describing them as an interconnected constitutional design.

Changing the number of vice presidents, the article said, would mean redefining the relationship between electoral mandates, power execution, and government continuity. While noting that Article 37 allows for constitutional amendments and that proposing three vice presidents is not in itself unconstitutional, the article argued the mere possibility of change does not automatically prove it to be necessary.

Kompas.com noted that Article 37 of the 1945 Constitution permits amendments, a process the Regional Representative Council (DPD) participates in as a component of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) during joint sittings with the People’s Representative Council (DPR) under the 2002 Fourth Amendment framework.

The outlet highlighted that while the DPD Chairman’s proposal for three vice presidents is not inherently unconstitutional, the council’s role in such a change would be legislative — proposing and voting on amendments — rather than executive, underscoring that the mere procedural possibility of amendment does not establish its necessity.

Ketua dpd ri sultan baktiar najamudin menghadiri malam puncak detikcom awards ondangdetikcom

In Indonesia’s presidential system, the President holds executive power and the vice president does not possess independent governance authority separate from the President. The article asked how the authority of three territorially assigned vice presidents would relate to that of ministers, governors, and local governments, and why three constitutional posts would be needed if they merely execute the President’s mandates.