A federal lawsuit filed Monday in Alexandria accuses ICE officers of stopping drivers and seizing passengers across Virginia without warrants or individualized suspicion.
The complaint, brought by six residents and the Centreville Immigration Forum, alleges that a January policy issued by then-acting Director Todd Lyons effectively erased the legal requirement that officers determine — person by person — whether someone is likely to flee before a warrant can be obtained.
Federal law permits warrantless immigration arrests only when officers have probable cause to believe a person is in the country unlawfully and is likely to escape before a warrant issues. The plaintiffs argue ICE has abandoned that second prong entirely.
“ICE agents are arresting people first and assuming they’ll figure out a reason to justify it later, flagrantly ignoring federal law that’s been in place for decades.”
said Sophia Gregg, senior supervising attorney at the ACLU of Virginia, which represents the plaintiffs alongside the Washington Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs.
The suit describes a July 13 encounter in which Alvaro Alvarez Flores, a Newport News resident of 14 years, was stopped while driving to work. He presented a valid Virginia driver’s license and told officers his sister and brother-in-law — both U.S. citizens — lived nearby. He was handcuffed anyway and driven around for roughly two hours before being taken to the Norfolk ICE office.
During that drive, the complaint alleges, an officer read passing license plates over the radio; when the database returned names that did not sound Hispanic, the officer said, “No, not that one.” When a Latino-sounding name came back, officers surrounded the vehicle, broke its windows and detained the occupants.

“Alvarez Flores did not observe officers using a computer or other records system during this process; instead, the officers appeared to rely on information received through the radio when deciding which vehicles to target,” the complaint says.
Another plaintiff, 18-year-old Britney Ramirez Corona, a U.S. citizen from Norfolk, was detained in August while trying to retrieve a vehicle after her fiancé’s arrest. She repeatedly told officers she was a citizen and had identification in her wallet. While she was handcuffed, her 4-year-old sister exited the car and was left to wander in a busy street, the lawsuit says.
The complaint cites a separate report estimating more than 15,000 ICE arrests in Virginia since January 2025. It also notes that the agency moved away from safeguards established in 2021 after an earlier lawsuit challenged warrantless arrests. The plaintiffs seek class-action status and an injunction blocking the practice.

The policy at the center of the case
The January directive from Lyons broadly defines “likely to flee” in a way that plaintiffs say allows officers to skip any case-by-case assessment of community ties, employment or family connections.
Rebecca Guterman, an attorney with the Washington Lawyers’ Committee, explained the legal threshold: “For decades, federal law has required that ICE can make an arrest if they have a warrant or if they have an individualized determination that the person is in the country unlawfully and that they are likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained.”
In Virginia, she said, the lawsuit demonstrates that officers “often don’t know who the person is or very much about them at all.”
A pattern the sources describe similarly
The lawsuit alleges several other examples of troubling conduct by ICE officers, including initiating an arrest by ramming into a van and pepper spraying its occupants. DHS did not respond to a request for comment about the lawsuit.
What remains unresolved
DHS did not respond to a request for comment about the lawsuit.