Lebanon Attorney Stephen Girdwood Recommended for Disbarment After Stealing $487,000 in Client Funds

A New Hampshire attorney discipline panel has unanimously recommended disbarment for Stephen Girdwood of Lebanon after he confessed to stealing $487,000 in escrow funds from a divorcing couple.

The recommendation, issued Wednesday by a four-member panel chaired by former Supreme Court Justice Peter Fauver, found clear and convincing evidence that Girdwood violated numerous rules of professional conduct, Valley News reported. Girdwood misappropriated the entirety of the funds he held for Keith and Athena Nicholson, diverting the money to personal expenses and a sports and entertainment venture in Florida.

“This man stole all of my money. I don’t even want to call him a man,” Keith Nicholson, 64, told the panel during a September hearing in Concord Probate Court. “He had no thought process on who he was going to hurt.”

The theft has left the Nicholsons, both in their 60s, living on Social Security. Athena Nicholson, 65, testified that the loss of her $195,000 share caused her emotional health to severely regress; she is disabled and unable to work. Keith Nicholson suffered a breakout of psoriasis and chest pain, was placed on blood thinners, and thought he had suffered a heart attack after losing his $292,000 portion, Valley News reported.

Escrow Agreement Leads to Betrayal and Missing Funds

The case traces back to May 2022, when the Nicholsons agreed to sell their marital home during divorce proceedings in 2nd Circuit Court–Lebanon Family Division. Girdwood, who represented Athena Nicholson, was designated as the escrow agent for the $487,000 in proceeds. A final default divorce decree in January 2025 awarded Keith Nicholson 60 percent, or $292,000, and Athena Nicholson 40 percent, or $195,000.

By the time the decree was issued, almost all the money was gone. Girdwood had drained the account to reimburse other clients, cover personal costs, and invest in Frozen Lake Sports and Entertainment, a Wyoming company he incorporated in 2020 with an Orlando address, according to a police report cited by Valley News.

Keith Nicholson’s anxiety mounted as the divorce dragged on. He repeatedly asked his attorney, Laura Dudziak, for a monthly accounting of the escrow funds. Each time, Valley News reported, she demurred: “He is an officer of the court. He would not dare touch that money. If he did, he would be disbarred and he would be thrown in jail.”

Confession, Criminal Referral, and the Discipline Process

In January, Girdwood confessed to Lebanon Police that he stole the Nicholsons’ funds along with money from other clients. Police opened a criminal investigation before referring the case to the FBI. Girdwood has since filed for bankruptcy, protecting his assets while the criminal probe continues, Valley News reported.

The New Hampshire Supreme Court issued an interim suspension order against Girdwood in January, followed by a reciprocal suspension from the Vermont Supreme Court in July. Girdwood has been licensed in both states since 1993.

At the September 22 sanctioning hearing, Girdwood, through his attorney Gary Apfel, invoked his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, acknowledging the adverse inference. He called no witnesses and offered no counter-evidence. The panel therefore weighed the facts as uncontested.

Chief Disciplinary Counsel Sara Greene presented the investigation’s findings. The panel noted Girdwood’s clean criminal record and voluntary confession as mitigating factors but wrote that they “do not greatly weigh in his favor in light of the breadth of Mr. Girdwood’s deliberate, knowing and dishonest acts, which occurred on multiple occasions for his own benefit and resulted in devastating injury to the Nicholsons, and an overall adverse impact upon public confidence in the legal profession.”

What Comes Next

The panel also recommended Girdwood reimburse the attorney discipline system for investigation and prosecution costs, estimated at roughly $4,600 by Greene. The Nicholsons are seeking reimbursement through the New Hampshire Supreme Court Public Protection Fund, which can pay claims once a disbarment order is issued.

Wednesday’s recommendation is not final. The case now moves to the Professional Conduct Committee for review, then to the Supreme Court for a final sanctioning order. “Only the Supreme Court can issue an order of disbarment,” Greene said. “This process could take a few months.”