The Legal Defense Fund filed an amicus brief Monday urging the Maryland Supreme Court to rule that police cannot stop someone based solely on the belief they are carrying a firearm, warning the practice would deepen racial disparities in a state where Black residents already face disproportionate enforcement.
The brief, filed Nov. 16 in Stephen Hunter v. State of Maryland, challenges a lower court ruling that denied Hunter’s motion to suppress evidence from a stop prompted by an officer’s belief he had a gun in his pocket. LDF argues that suspected firearm possession without evidence of unlawful conduct fails the Fourth Amendment’s reasonable suspicion standard established in Terry v. Ohio.
“The record contains no evidence that officers reasonably suspected Hunter lacked a valid handgun permit,” the filing says. Maryland law permits individuals with valid permits to carry handguns in public, and the revised licensing system took effect Oct. 1, 2023, after the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen eliminated the state’s “good and substantial reason” requirement.
The brief cites a 2026 Appellate Court of Maryland decision, Hicks v. State, which found that an investigative stop based on suspected handgun possession requires reasonable suspicion the individual lacks legal authorization.
“Allowing stops based solely on suspected firearm possession could subject more people engaged in lawful conduct to unnecessary police encounters.”
Legal Defense Fund amicus brief
The organization argues such behavior may have innocent explanations and that reasonable suspicion requires examining the totality of circumstances rather than vague descriptions of conduct.
The stakes are measurable.
The state has characterized a brief investigative stop as a minor intrusion, according to LDF’s filing. The brief also cited research associating frequent police encounters with anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder, disruptions to daily routines, and diminished civic and political participation.