Liverpool Fan Found Not Guilty After Semenyo Withdraws Support for Prosecution

A Liverpool supporter accused of racially abusing Antoine Semenyo was cleared on Friday after the Manchester City forward withdrew his support for the prosecution, collapsing the case at Liverpool Magistrates’ Court.

Mark Mogan, 47, of Templehill Close in Dovecot, had denied a charge of racially aggravated behaviour during the Premier League match between Liverpool and Bournemouth at Anfield on 15 August last year. Semenyo, who played for Bournemouth at the time and joined Manchester City in January, had been expected to give evidence against him.

Prosecutor Simon Jones told District Judge Mary Dowrick that Semenyo had recently indicated he was no longer supportive of the proceedings and the Crown did not consider it appropriate to compel him. The prosecution offered no further evidence, and the judge recorded a verdict of not guilty.

“Following recent contact made with Mr Semenyo, he has indicated he is no longer supportive of proceedings and the prosecution do not consider it is appropriate to compel him. In those circumstances we offer no further evidence in the case.”

— Simon Jones, prosecuting, in court Friday

Trial resumes after defendant's seizure

The trial had originally opened last month but was halted halfway through when Mogan suffered a seizure in court and was taken to hospital. Mogan, who uses a wheelchair and was accompanied by an intermediary, returned for the resumed hearing on Friday.

Liverpool Fan Found Not Guilty After Semenyo Withdraws Support for Prosecution
Photo: theguardian.com

Opening the case last month, Jones told the court that Mogan shouted abuse at Semenyo as the player prepared to take a throw-in roughly 30 minutes into the game. The alleged words were: “Hurry up and take the throw-in, you black bastard.”

“That racial abuse was shouted directly at Antoine Semenyo, who was close to him. Mr Semenyo briefly froze, as he couldn’t believe what the male had said.”

— Simon Jones, prosecuting, at the earlier hearing

Mr Jones

Mogan then shouted “I’m talking to you, you cunt,” the court heard. Witnesses also reported seeing him throw chewing gum at the footballer. Semenyo reported the incident to the referee, and Mogan was removed from the stadium at half-time.

Prosecution offers no evidence after witness withdraws

In a police interview, Mogan claimed Semenyo had called him a cripple after he shouted at the player to “hurry up.” The Guardian reported that Mogan declined to comment as he left court on Friday.

The not-guilty verdict was a formal consequence of the prosecution’s decision to offer no evidence once its key witness withdrew. It does not constitute a finding that the alleged abuse did not occur, only that the case could not proceed without Semenyo’s testimony.

Antoine Semenyo, born in England in 2000, began his career at Bristol City after unsuccessful trials with Arsenal, Tottenham Hotspur and Millwall, and a rejection by Crystal Palace at age 15. He broke through in the 2020–21 season, winning the club’s Young Player of the Year award, and earned a £10 million move to Bournemouth in January 2023.

A £64 million transfer took him to Manchester City three years later, where he scored the only goal in the FA Cup final to secure the trophy in his first half-season.

Why the withdrawal matters

Semenyo has not commented publicly on his decision. Manchester City and Liverpool have not issued statements. Mogan’s seizure last month delayed the process but did not alter the evidential problem that emerged when Semenyo signalled he would not continue.