Advance Colorado Sues to Overturn Amendment 87, Citing TABOR Violation

Voters approved Amendment 87 with 51.72% of the vote, and the conservative group Advance Colorado filed a lawsuit Thursday to overturn it, Chalkbeat reported.

The suit, filed in Denver District Court on behalf of Republican state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer and Byron Pelton, argues the measure violated the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights by bundling two distinct changes — stripping TABOR’s flat-tax language from the constitution and imposing a new graduated rate structure in statute — into a single ballot question.

“It’s clear that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two measures, not a single one,” Kirkmeyer said in a statement included in an Advance Colorado news release. “The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned.”

Advance Colorado also claims the state’s Blue Book voter guide misled thousands of taxpayers. The guide’s tax tables used adjusted gross income rather than Colorado taxable income, the group alleges, telling filers they would receive a cut when they will actually owe thousands more each year.

Chris deGruy Kennedy, president of the Bell Policy Center and a leader of the Amendment 87 coalition, told Chalkbeat the tables were accurate but acknowledged “a policy discussion to be had there about which one of those two figures offers the clearest information to voters.”

Denver district court downtown co

Gov. Jared Polis and the Department of Revenue director are named as defendants. A Polis administration spokesperson declined to comment on the pending litigation, Chalkbeat reported. The governor’s own November 12 briefing to the Joint Budget Committee has become a centerpiece of the complaint.

“If you don’t rein in Medicaid, all of the 87 money goes to Medicaid. Zero for education, zero for actually making people healthier, zero for early childhood,” Polis told lawmakers, warning that Medicaid growth could consume every new dollar within three years. Advance Colorado quotes that passage to argue the measure promises education funding it cannot deliver.

The Medicaid squeeze

Colorado faces a more than $1 billion budget deficit driven largely by rising Medicaid costs. Kennedy countered that he expects a “very healthy increase in funding” for K-12, health care, and early childhood programs. State estimates project the six-tier graduated tax could raise up to $2 billion in 2028, replacing the current 4.4% flat rate. Households earning above $500,000 in taxable income would pay more; most Coloradans would pay less.

Third attempt to block the measure

This is the third legal challenge from conservative groups. The state Title Board and the Colorado Supreme Court previously rejected a single-subject challenge, and the high court also dismissed a petition-signature lawsuit.

Advance Colorado’s 2027 countermeasure

One day before filing suit, Advance Colorado announced it had submitted 2027 ballot proposals to “reverse the destructive impact of Amendment 87.”

The group’s president, Michael Fields, said the plan would eliminate income taxes for people and businesses earning $100,000 or less and restore a 4.4% flat rate above that threshold — a change he said would reduce state revenue by billions but leave per-capita spending comparable to Nevada, North Carolina, and New Hampshire. “We have a government that has been growing faster than wages every year and that’s not sustainable,” Fields said.

Advance Colorado Sues to Overturn Amendment 87, Citing TABOR Violation

Voters rejected Advance Colorado’s Proposition 136 this month, which would have capped the income tax rate at 4.4%.

Proposition NN adds separate education revenue

Amendment 87 was one of two revenue measures approved for education. Proposition NN, which lifts the TABOR revenue cap that triggers taxpayer refunds, is projected to raise billions specifically for K-12 programs.