Both lungs were missing from the body of an 18-year-old boating collision victim when an independent pathologist attempted a second post-mortem examination, prompting his family to demand an urgent investigation.
Amiyr Ali was one of six passengers killed when the 28-foot pleasure craft BAMBALEO collided with the 29-foot vessel BELBAGAI off the coast of Chaguaramas on November 8 at approximately 6:30 p.m. While Ali’s body was eventually recovered and released to Muslim Funeral Services, the initial state post-mortem examination at the Forensic Science Centre listed his cause of death as “undetermined.”
Dissatisfied with the state findings and observing that part of Ali’s face—including his upper jaw, nose, and forehead—had been destroyed in the collision, the family retained anatomic and forensic pathologist Dr. Hughvon Des Vignes to perform a second examination. When Des Vignes attempted the private autopsy, he discovered that both lungs were absent from the remains.
In an email to the family, Des Vignes described the absence of the organs as “grossly irregular” and indicative of “gross negligence.” Although his examination indicated that Ali died from traumatic injuries, Des Vignes said that the assessment remained incomplete without the lungs, particularly because the victim was recovered from the sea.
Des Vignes issued a Medical Certificate of Cause of Death dated November 19, recording the cause as “multiple traumatic injuries.” Attorney Anand Ramlogan SC, representing the family, said that relatives are struggling to reconcile the severe facial trauma with the Forensic Science Centre’s failure to establish a definitive cause of death during the initial state autopsy.
A relative told Guardian Media that she was concerned the missing organs might taint the investigation, potentially preventing manslaughter charges from being pursued. The relative said that while Des Vignes advised on traumatic injuries, there was no way to confirm if drowning was the cause of death.
The family’s legal representation is pressing the Forensic Science Centre to clarify whether the organs were stored separately, misplaced, mislabelled, or released alongside another person’s remains, or if they were withheld, concealed, or destroyed.
Ramlogan called for the immediate location and securing of the organs under a documented chain of custody so that Des Vignes can complete his evaluation. Furthermore, the family has demanded the preservation of all post-mortem records, notes, photographs, specimen labels, transfer documents, electronic audit trails, and CCTV footage.
Beyond Ali’s case, the family’s legal team has urged an independent inquiry into the post-mortem examinations and the release of remains for all six victims of the Chaguaramas collision, raising concerns over whether procedures were properly followed across the board. Meanwhile, commercial divers are expected to examine the wreckage of the sunken vessel, and investigators continue consulting with the Director of Public Prosecutions regarding the case.
The Chaguaramas peninsula, located on the Northwest Peninsula of Trinidad, holds significant historical and political weight. In 1940, the entire area was leased to the United States for the construction of a naval base, which operated until its return to local control in 1963.
Beyond its military history, the area is a landmark for regional diplomacy; it was the site where the 1973 Treaty of Chaguaramas was signed, establishing the Caribbean Community and Common Market, known as CARICOM.
Amiyr’s family waited for him to be brought home. They should never have had to ask where his lungs are, Ramlogan said.