A Montpelier woman was sentenced Thursday to at least 14 years in prison for breaking into her ex-husband’s Alvordton home and firing shots at him in May, Bryan Times reported.
Williams County Common Pleas Court Judge Rhonda Fisher imposed an indefinite sentence of 14 to 17.5 years, with 185 days credit for time already served. Amanda S. Heller, 31, had pleaded guilty in October to felonious assault, burglary, domestic violence and improperly discharging a firearm at a habitation — charges reduced from attempted aggravated murder and aggravated burglary under a plea agreement.
The prosecution pushed for 15 years
Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Emile Gravelle asked for a combined 15 years. Defense attorney Kati Tharp requested community control, arguing Heller did not go to the house intending to kill her ex-husband. The judge disagreed after reviewing body-camera footage from Heller’s arrest.
“Without having heard anything here this morning, just reading through the presentence investigation, for whatever reason, I have no doubt that you went to (the victim’s) house to kill him.”
Fisher said from the bench. She pointed to video showing a deputy finding a fully loaded spare magazine on Heller and to audio in which Heller is heard saying she was sorry she missed.
Alcohol addiction framed as the ‘demon’
Both sides agreed Heller had been drinking heavily the morning of the incident. During her allocution, Heller said she had struggled with alcohol addiction for years and had been sober for six months since her arrest.
“I realized I was not in control of it, and I was in denial of my addiction the whole time.”
Heller said through tears. “This is not who I am. I’m a caring daughter, a loving sister, a devoted girlfriend, and most of all, a mother to two amazing girls. And I have fallen short in every single relationship.”
Fisher told Heller she believed alcohol was the driving force.
“You’ve admitted to having alcohol use almost daily, marijuana use almost daily, and I fully believe that contributed to this incident.”
Ex-husband testifies about armed standoff and 911 call
Heller’s ex-husband told the court she called him repeatedly before driving roughly 20 minutes to his house. He said he was in bed when she entered his bedroom and fired a shot. He grabbed his own handgun; the two pointed weapons at each other until he ordered her out of the room. She fired a second shot in another room, he said.
The victim said Heller’s boyfriend had followed her to the house and was sitting in the driveway. When the victim asked the boyfriend to call 911, he refused.
The victim escaped to a neighbor’s outbuilding and called 911 himself — but because he was near the Michigan line, his call routed to an out-of-state dispatch center and had to be transferred to Williams County. Deputies apprehended Heller driving nearby, apparently still looking for the victim.