Motley Rice Attorney Ashley Hornstein Appointed Co-Lead Counsel in Rhode Island Child Sex Abuse Litigation

Motley Rice attorney Ashley Hornstein has been named plaintiffs’ co-lead counsel in Rhode Island’s coordinated child sexual abuse litigation, a mass tort proceeding established in Superior Court on July 1 to manage claims revived by a new two-year lookback window.

The appointment, announced by the firm, places Hornstein at the helm of In Re: Child Sex Abuse, C.A. No. PC-2026-88888, where she will shape plaintiffs’ positions on procedural and substantive issues common to the cases. The litigation targets institutions, religious orders, and individuals alleged to have caused or enabled abuse.

“There are cases that remind you why you became a lawyer, and then there are cases that define what it means to be one,” Hornstein said in a statement provided to Motley Rice.

“For me, this litigation is both. These survivors were children when they suffered harm no child should ever have to endure. Many have carried that pain for decades. We cannot change what happened to them, but we can help change what happens next. They deserve their day in court, and I can think of few causes more worthy of the fight.”

The legal architecture behind the docket

The coordinated proceeding exists because the General Assembly enacted legislation in June creating a revival window that runs from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2028. The law allows survivors whose civil claims were previously time-barred to sue both individual abusers and the institutions that enabled them. It followed months after Attorney General Peter F. Neronha released an investigation reviewing more than 250,000 pages of diocesan records dating to 1950.

That report found 75 priests employed by the Diocese of Providence from 1950 to 2022 had been credibly accused of abusing more than 300 children. It also documented historical failures to consistently report allegations to law enforcement. Neronha said victims in the Church take an average of 26 years to come forward, a finding that mirrors the national average.

Attorney General moves to defend the statute

On Tuesday, November 17, Neronha moved to intervene in several ongoing cases against the Diocese of Providence to defend the constitutionality of the revival window. The motion, filed in Superior Court, argues the amendments are entitled to a presumption of constitutionality and that the burden rests on defendants to prove otherwise.

The Diocese has challenged the law’s validity, and both the Superior Court and the U.S. District Court are exploring certifying questions to the Rhode Island Supreme Court regarding the window’s constitutionality.

“Survivors of child sexual abuse within the Diocese of Providence have been denied justice for decades as a result of a systemic pattern of protecting the reputation of the Church and its priests over the welfare of children,” Neronha said in a press release from his office.

“The pain that survivors suffer knows no statute of limitations, and they deserve to seek accountability from the people and institutions that enabled these crimes.”

The Attorney General’s motion also argues certification is premature because the record is insufficient and the challenging party has not yet identified specific bases for its constitutional challenge. Neronha testified in support of the revival window before the Senate Judiciary Committee on May 14.

Hornstein ashley j

What the coordinated proceeding changes for survivors

The mass tort docket centralizes pretrial management for claims that would otherwise proceed in isolation. For survivors, this means shared discovery, consistent rulings on common legal questions, and a structured path toward resolution. The defendants include institutions and religious orders as well as individuals, broadening the scope of potential accountability beyond the Diocese alone.

Hornstein’s role as co-lead counsel involves coordinating strategy across plaintiffs’ firms, briefing common motions, and liaising with the court on case management orders. The proceeding provides survivors an opportunity to pursue accountability from institutions they allege caused, enabled, or failed to prevent their abuse.

The constitutional fight ahead

The Diocese’s challenge to the revival window sets up a high-stakes test of legislative power to revive expired civil claims. The Attorney General’s intervention signals the state’s commitment to defending the law, but the courts’ interest in certifying questions to the Supreme Court suggests a definitive ruling may take time.

Neronha intends to intervene in federal court as well to defend the law’s constitutionality there. The motion notes the General Assembly passed the amendments with the Attorney General’s support.

Motley Rice LLC, the plaintiffs’ litigation firm representing Hornstein, was formed in 2003 in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, by Ron Motley and Joseph F. Rice after the dissolution of their prior firm, Ness, Motley, Loadholdt, Richardson & Poole.

Ron Motley previously served as lead attorney in the 1990s tobacco litigation that produced the Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement, and the firm represented approximately 96,000 asbestos plaintiffs by 2004. Among its notable alumni is John J. McConnell Jr., now Chief Judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island.

The revival window closes June 30, 2028.