Nashville SC opens the MLS Cup playoffs this week carrying the weight of the greatest regular season in the league’s 31-year history, a 77-point campaign that left Lionel Messi’s Inter Miami CF 17 points adrift in second place.
The Supporters’ Shield winners (23-3-8) kick off their postseason at GEODIS Park, where they went 15-0-2 this year, the best home record MLS has ever seen. Yet history offers a cold warning: only one team in the last nine seasons — Los Angeles FC in 2022 — has managed to convert a Shield into an MLS Cup trophy.
Sacha Kljestan, a former MLS midfielder and current Apple TV analyst who was on the 2015 New York Red Bulls team that won the Shield but fell short in the playoffs, said Nashville must be ready from the first whistle because the Red Bulls conceded after nine seconds in the Eastern Conference final against Columbus Crew.
Kljestan added that falling behind puts a team behind the eight ball, forcing it to dig and claw to get back into the game, which is not a spot Nashville has been in much this year.
That 2015 Red Bulls side, which also featured analyst Dax McCarty, finished with 60 points — 17 fewer than this Nashville squad — but the psychological trap remains the same. McCarty told Forbes he was impressed by Nashville’s tactical versatility but warned that managing emotions will decide the title.
“I think managing emotions is probably going to be the key for Nashville SC because they can play in any type of game,” McCarty said.
“We’ve seen that from them. We’ve seen them be able to be effective in all kinds of different games. If they need to sit and see how to win and defend, they can do that. If they need to press, if they need to send numbers forward, if they need to be aggressive, counter-pressing, high line, you name it.”
The individual hardware has piled up in Music City over the last week. Defender Maxwell Woledzi claimed Defender of the Year honors on Nov. 16, beating out teammates Jeisson Palacios and Andy Najar for the award.
Two days later, goalkeeper Brian Schwake was named Goalkeeper of the Year. Hany Mukhtar is a finalist for league MVP, Sam Surridge finished third in scoring with 21 goals, and coach B.J. Callaghan is the heavy favorite for Coach of the Year.
Only 11 Shield winners have ever lifted the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy, a 36.6 percent success rate over three decades. The league’s early years were friendlier to dominant regular-season teams — D.C. United pulled the double in 1997 and 1999 — but the playoff format has since turned the postseason into a distinct, seven-game sprint where a single bad night erases months of excellence.

McCarty downplayed the value of home-field advantage in the knockout rounds, recalling how Red Bulls teams often conceded “fantastic finishes” and failed to respond when trailing. “I don’t think we managed going behind really well,” he said. “We didn’t stay composed. We made mistakes. We missed big chances in the final third.”
Mukhtar, born in Berlin in 1995, became Nashville SC’s first designated player in August 2019 after the club acquired his rights from Seattle Sounders FC for $100,000 in general allocation money. He agreed to join partly because his mother was a fan of Johnny Cash and knew of the singer’s connection to the city.
Mukhtar scored the fastest hat-trick from the start of a game in MLS history — three goals inside the first 16 minutes against Chicago Fire FC on July 17, 2021. He was named the 2022 Landon Donovan MLS MVP after leading the league with 34 goal contributions (23 goals, 11 assists) and captained Nashville to the 2026 Supporters’ Shield.
Inter Miami, Vancouver Whitecaps FC, and the rest of the bracket will try to exploit that vulnerability. The MLS Cup final is scheduled for Dec. 18.