New Mexico judges and magistrates will vest in their retirement plans faster and reach higher maximum pensions under a proposal approved by the state’s Judicial Compensation Commission on Tuesday.
Courthouse News Service reported that the changes align judicial retirement terms with the state’s general employee benefits plan. Commissioners unanimously voted to reduce the vesting period from eight years to five years while raising the maximum pension cap from 85% to 100% of a judge’s final average salary.
The state administers these pension programs through sub-funds managed by the Public Employees Retirement Association, covering justices under the New Mexico Judicial Retirement Act and magistrates under the Magistrate Retirement Act.

Financial pressures prompted the structural updates. A Legislative Finance Committee fiscal impact report showed the judicial retirement fund has been underfunded for years, holding $214.3 million in total liabilities against $120.2 million in total assets as of June 2024, according to data from the Public Employees Retirement Association.
To address the shortfall, the commission initially requested an evaluation of a 4% service credit for a judge’s first or next ten years of service, up from 3.25%. After the Public Employees Retirement Association found that change would not solve the deficit, the commission dropped the idea.
Removing the increased credit means the state and individual judges will contribute slightly more each year. Karl Reifsteck, director of the Administrative Office of the Courts and staff to the commission, said that the adjustment gets the system back on track.

“It gets us back in the right direction,” Reifsteck said.
The revised strategy places the Judicial Retirement Act on a 58-year path toward solvency. Meanwhile, modifications to the Magistrate Retirement Act accelerate that fund’s financial stability timeline from 37 years down to 24 years.
Four members attended the Tuesday meeting to authorize the changes: Camille Carey, chair of the commission and dean of the University of New Mexico School of Law; Allison Block-Chavez, president of the State Bar of New Mexico; Patrick Ortiz, a retired Santa Fe attorney appointed by the Chief Justice of the state Supreme Court; and Kathryn Brack Morrow, a Las Cruces attorney appointed by the New Mexico Senate’s president pro tempore.