New Stores at Mayfaire and Independence Mall in 2026, Reports Star-News

Wilmington shoppers walking into Independence Mall this week will find a Toys R Us where a calendar store used to be, the first time the brand has had a local storefront since it shuttered on Oleander Drive in 2018.

The return anchors a wave of new tenants at both Independence Mall and Mayfaire Town Center ahead of Black Friday on November 27, the Wilmington StarNews reported Friday. At Mayfaire, Ben & Jerry’s has taken over the former Cold Stone Creamery space, while Lovesac and Flip Flop Shops opened earlier in the year and Rack Room Shoes expanded its footprint.

“The openings and expansions give Wilmington shoppers more options as holiday spending gets underway,” the StarNews said, adding that retail experts anticipate a strong season after a robust back-to-school period at Mayfaire.

Flat gouache-painted editorial illustration of stacked plain gift boxes beside an empty shopping bag against a muted teal
Photo: wisevoter.com

Independence Mall leans into experience

The most striking shift at Independence Mall is the arrival of Discovery Bay, a mini-aquarium operated by the North Carolina Aquarium at Fort Fisher that opened July 8. It sits alongside a new Build-A-Bear Workshop stand and Giftmasters Laser Engraving, both added in 2026. Toys R Us replaced Go! Calendars, Toys & Games, a direct swap of one seasonal-heavy tenant for another.

CBL Properties, the real estate investment trust that owns Independence Mall, has not released foot-traffic or sales figures for the new locations. The StarNews did not report any totals, and WiseVoter explicitly noted their absence.

Mayfaire swaps dessert for sofas and sandals

At Mayfaire, the tenant mix skews toward home furnishings and footwear. Lovesac began selling its modular sofas, sectionals, and home-audio bundles earlier this year. Flip Flop Shops, a sandal-and-casual-shoe retailer, also opened in 2026. Rack Room Shoes expanded its existing store, adding square footage in a center that has historically performed well during back-to-school.

Ben & Jerry’s opening in the former Cold Stone space marks the only pure food-and-beverage addition mentioned in either center’s 2026 roster.

Black Friday pressure test arrives next week

Retailers at Mayfaire have been increasing inventory and hiring ahead of the November 27 holiday kickoff, six days from the StarNews reporting date. WiseVoter cited local observation that foot traffic at the open-air center tends to build later in the afternoon, suggesting morning visits may offer lighter crowds for shoppers planning Black Friday trips.

The StarNews published its roundup on November 21 at 5:02 a.m. ET. WiseVoter published its corroborating report the same day.