Reinaldo Dennes told the warden to “Go,” and his leg caught fire.
That is the image that lingers from the execution chamber in Huntsville on Thursday night: a 70-year-old man strapped to a gurney, IV lines finally threaded through his neck and left foot after a prolonged struggle to find a vein, crying out that his right leg — the one without a line — was burning. He was pronounced dead at 7:08 p.m., 16 minutes after the pentobarbital began to flow, KWTX reported.
Rev. Jeff Hood, who has witnessed 15 executions as a spiritual adviser, had his hand on Dennes’s shoulder the entire time. “It felt like trying to grab hold of a bucking bronco,” Hood said Friday. “Immediately, you’re supposed to … lose consciousness very quickly, and what happened, it was unquestionably botched.”
The Texas Department of Criminal Justice disagrees. “The agency followed its protocols,” spokesperson Amanda Hernandez said in a statement, adding that Dennes’s complaints of pain began before any drugs were administered and noting the IVs were placed in his left foot and left neck — not the right leg where he screamed the fire was.

A witness and an agency tell different stories
Hood does not accept the agency’s timeline. “My hand was on Reinaldo’s shoulder the entire time I was in that chamber,” he said in a Friday news release. “I know what I saw. … Texas does not get to tell a different story.”
The Associated Press reporter in the chamber corroborated the prolonged distress: Dennes moaned and prayed for nearly three minutes after the injection began, shouting “Take me father!” and “The pain!” while his chest flexed off the gurney. Hood said inmates typically fall silent within 30 seconds; Dennes kept speaking and struggling for nearly five minutes.
TDCJ told the Associated Press that Dennes may have been exaggerating the pain. Joel Zivot, an anesthesiology professor at Emory University, called that claim “shocking” in comments to CBS Austin. “If you make such a claim, then prove it. And you could prove it by simply performing an autopsy,” said Joel Zivot, an anesthesiology professor at Emory University.
The drug supply chain under scrutiny
Dennes’s execution is the second in as many months labeled “botched” in the United States. In October, Tennessee’s Christa Pike survived two failed lethal injection attempts. Both states use pentobarbital sourced from compounding pharmacies — state-regulated facilities that mix drugs without federal oversight — a workaround adopted after major pharmaceutical manufacturers blocked their products for executions around 2011.
Texas has kept its supply flowing in part by extending expiration dates, retesting potency and relabeling doses. Death penalty attorneys have argued for years that degraded or compounded pentobarbital can cause excruciating deaths, but legal challenges have not succeeded. TDCJ has not responded to questions about whether the drug used Thursday came from an expired or retested batch.
Dennes joined a lawsuit with two other death row inmates, LeJames Norman and John Rubio, challenging the state’s pentobarbital supply as unreliable. The state’s 15th Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal on Nov. 9, ruling it lacked jurisdiction because the laws governing the drug fall under criminal, not civil, law. The Texas Supreme Court denied a subsequent petition. Norman and Rubio were executed earlier this year.

Thirty years on death row
In 1996, Dennes shot and killed Houston jeweler Janos Szucs during a robbery that netted $3.6 million in diamonds and $200,000 in cash — never recovered. A security guard was also injured.
At trial, David Balderas testified that he helped Dennes and two others plan a 1995 burglary, linking Dennes to a second crime. Dennes’s final appeals, including one filed Nov. 12, argued Balderas was a police informant whose status Houston police concealed, and that his testimony should have been impeached. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denied relief Wednesday. The U.S. Supreme Court denied a stay Thursday.
Before the drugs started, Dennes delivered a final statement: “I just want my family and loved ones to know that I have been extremely blessed these 30 years,” he said, speaking of the “great grace of God.” Then he told the warden, “Go.”
An execution pace not seen in years
Dennes was the ninth person Texas has executed in 2026 — the most in a single year this decade. The state put three people to death in some recent years. It marked its 600th execution of the modern era in May. Three more executions are scheduled for 2027.
Corinna Lain, a University of Richmond law professor who has studied the death penalty for two decades, told CBS Austin the witness accounts point to unequivocal failure. “All of those things suggest, in unequivocal terms, that something went wrong in this execution.”
Fordham law professor Deborah Denno added that corrections departments routinely avoid accountability in lethal injection cases. “I’ve never seen a situation where a state has proactively made a department of corrections in any kind of lethal injection process take accountability in the way that most of the public would assume that they would.”
Hood, the spiritual adviser, has called for TDCJ Executive Director Bobby Lumpkin to resign or be fired. “The people of Texas should be absolutely disgusted that their state officials are willing to lie to them so brazenly,” he said.
He also warned of the cost to the victim’s family: “The rest of time in history, nobody’s gonna be talking about the victim. Everybody is gonna be talking about this botched execution.”