Chengdu University Study Finds Atmosphere Gained Oxygen in Three Pulses

Earth’s atmosphere gained oxygen in three distinct pulses, each arriving hundreds of millions of years before the deep ocean caught up, a new study from Chengdu University of Technology finds.

The research, published March 17 in The Innovation, rewrites the textbook timeline of planetary oxygenation. The record shows the Great Oxidation Event unchanged at 2.4–2.1 billion years ago. It shifts the second and third rises to 1.3–1.0 billion and 0.44–0.41 billion years ago.

That means the well-known Neoproterozoic and Paleozoic oxygenation events, long dated to 800–540 million and 420–360 million years ago, actually record the ocean’s delayed response. The ocean lagged the atmosphere by roughly 200 million and 30 million years.

“Earth's surface oxygenation was a protracted, multi-step process,” the authors write. “It is widely accepted that atmospheric O2 rose through three major steps, each closely linked to key evolutionary innovations,” said Haiyang Wang and Chao Li, geochemists at the Chengdu University of Technology.

Sulfate isotopes track the air, not the sea

For decades, scientists read ancient ocean redox from the rock record as a proxy for atmospheric oxygen. But ocean chemistry also answers to nutrients, productivity, circulation and basin shape. That makes it an imperfect mirror of the air.

The Chengdu team instead used sulfate triple-oxygen isotopes (Δ′¹⁷O). Atmospheric oxygen carries a characteristic deficit in oxygen-17, manufactured by O₂–O₃–CO₂ photochemistry. That fingerprint passes into sulfate when sulfide minerals weather. Sedimentary sulfate therefore archives the atmosphere.

On that record, the first rise lifted oxygen from below one part per million of modern levels to somewhere between 0.1% and 10%. Models calibrated to the isotope data place the mid-Proterozoic atmosphere at just 0.1–1% of today’s concentration. Charcoal, which needs roughly three-quarters of modern oxygen to form, appears only around 420 million years ago. That matches the third atmospheric pulse.

Atmosphere and ocean diverged on million-year timescales

The two reservoirs climbed together across billion-year spans. On shorter, million-year scales they could move in opposite directions. A pulse of oxygen entering the ocean oxidized stored organic carbon and sulfide, consuming the gas and pulling atmospheric levels down.

“Whereas on shorter, million-year timescales, their redox states could diverge, exhibiting negative coupling,” the authors write. Many geological spikes once read as oxygen increases may instead mark its retreat. Arrows that should point down, not up.

Ocean oxygenation was also patchy. Photosynthetic microbes created localized oxygen oases in shallow waters as early as 3 billion years ago, dominating the Archean. Oxygen supplied from the atmosphere became increasingly important later. The ocean interior did not become fully oxygenated until about 410 million years ago.

Life tracked oxygen without being simply triggered by it

The biological consequences unfolded in stages. Under an anoxic atmosphere, oxygen was a hard limit for aerobic life. Through the Proterozoic it became a permissive factor, opening niches while animals evolved under fluctuating levels. Only after the third rise did oxygen actively amplify complexity. It enabled larger bodies, active predation and expansion into deeper habitats.

“Earth's surface oxygenation history reflects a dynamic and nonlinear interplay among atmospheric O2 evolution, land and ocean redox buffering, and ecological innovation,” the authors write.

Limits and next steps

The authors are candid about constraints. Isotope resolution is coarse. Absolute oxygen levels after 1 billion years ago remain poorly constrained. Further steps in the long transition may be invisible. The study was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China and the National Natural Science Foundation of China.

Chengdu University of Technology traces its roots to the 1956 founding of Chengdu Institute of Geology, assembled from geology faculties of six major universities with State Council approval. It became Chengdu Institute of Technology in 1993 and adopted its current name in 2001, now jointly administered by the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Natural Resources, and the Sichuan provincial government.

The university holds a first-level National Key Discipline in Geological Resources and Geological Engineering, and its Institute of Sedimentary Geology aligns directly with the deep-time isotope work behind the new oxygenation study.

“These deep-time perspectives illuminate the co-evolution of life and Earth's surface environments and provide a conceptual framework for evaluating planetary habitability,” they conclude.