NTSB Says Improper Maintenance Contributed to Kamaka Air 2024 Crash Near Honolulu

“I would never in a million years want this to happen to anybody,” Tamar deFries-Saronitman said, according to Hawaii News Now. “Nobody should ever have to bury their child because of this.”

Federal investigators have determined that improper maintenance and a flap-system failure contributed to a 2024 airplane crash near Honolulu that killed two pilots, according to Routes News and Yahoo. In its final investigation report, the National Transportation Safety Board said the Cessna 208B left-wing flap system failed during an instructional flight shortly after takeoff from Daniel K. Inouye International Airport on Dec. 17, 2024.

The plane rolled left and struck a vacant, state-owned building, killing flight instructor Preston Kaluhiwa, 26, and pilot Hiram deFries-Saronitman, 24. The aircraft reached a maximum altitude of about 350 feet above ground.

NTSB Says Improper Maintenance Contributed to Kamaka Air 2024 Crash Near Honolulu
Photo: yahoo.com

Stress caused by improper maintenance triggered the failure of a linkage rod within the left-wing flap mechanism, concluded the NTSB. Because of this malfunction, the left flap shifted out of alignment, generating a discrepancy between the aircraft’s flaps and an unintended left roll while flying too low for recovery.

Additionally, investigators discovered that the crash was fueled by Kamaka Air neglecting its Federal Aviation Administration-approved maintenance regimen, alongside deficient oversight and instruction for its mechanics.

About 10 weeks before the crash, the company replaced the plane’s primary flap motor after a pilot reported that the flaps failed to retract after landing. Investigators stated they could not determine whether the flap system was improperly adjusted during that work or earlier. Following the accident, Kamaka Air checked flap travel and cable tension on the remaining Cessna 208 series planes in its fleet and corrected the discrepancies identified.

Kamaka Air said that it cooperated fully with the investigation and will carefully review the report.

NTSB: Improper maintenance led to deadly Kamaka Air crash — Hawaii News Now

“Preston and Hiram were, and always will be, our ‘ohana,” CEO Peter Banfield said in a statement reported by Hawaii News Now. “We still feel their loss every day, and we share it with their families and our community. Our hearts are with them, especially today.”

The company added that it would not comment further out of respect for the families and ongoing legal matters.

NTSB Says Improper Maintenance Contributed to Kamaka Air 2024 Crash Near Honolulu
Photo: routes-news.com

Yahoo reports that Hiram’s relatives are moving forward with a civil lawsuit aimed at Kamaka Air, the maintenance provider, and the aircraft manufacturer. Inafuku added, “We now turn our full attention to pursuing those responsible and holding them accountable so that this never happens again.”

Friends of Hiram continue to gather for Friday night barbecues at his family’s home and take his boat out to catch tunas, which was his favorite, according to close friend Kahi Bisho. Friend Moku Dancil-Evans noted, “The report’s the report. I think we all knew deep down how great a pilot that he was. Preston as well.”

Kamaka Air was founded in 1993 as a local airline operating across the Hawaiian islands. Certified by the Federal Aviation Administration, the company functions as an inter-island logistics firm specializing in per-pound air cargo services and non-scheduled charters. The organization is known for utilizing single-engine Cessna Caravan aircraft, which are capable of the short landings and takeoffs necessary to serve small communities on Molokai and Lanai.

“That’s really all that the report did for me. I just miss having him here,” Dancil-Evans said.