The National Union of Peoples’ Lawyers (NUPL) criticized President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s remark that there is no deal yet regarding the Pax Silica protests, citing government actions supporting the initiative.
Marcos stated that there will not be data centers in the planned development site for Pax Silica, clarifying that the project aims to broaden technology commodities and support artificial intelligence (AI) globally.
The NUPL noted several government initiatives supporting the project, including the Philippines and United States signing of a Critical Minerals Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on February 4, 2026 ].
The NUPL argued that the government’s insistence on the MOU being nonbinding is a way to dismiss public opposition as premature, pointing to the Bases Conversion and Development Authority and Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority’s agreement identifying Subic Bay as Pax Silica’s preferred maritime gateway.

Further actions cited by the NUPL include the issuance of Executive Order No. 122 in August, which frameworks the critical minerals industry, and House Bill No. 11758 seeking a Pax Silica Advanced Industries Zone in New Clark City in Tarlac .
Human Rights Watch reported that the construction under the Pax Silica initiative could displace hundreds of Indigenous peoples and farmers in Tarlac province, including the Indigenous Aeta tribe, as the Philippine government would provide the land .
The NUPL stressed that Marcos should address constitutional, environmental, and social objections to Pax Silica rather than professing bewilderment, adding that the administration responded to opposition at the Asean Summit with mass arrests and criminal complaints against protesters .
The question of how Marcos’ remark that “there is no deal yet” addresses the concerns of affected communities remains unstated.