Olukayode Taiwo Arrested in Connecticut for Philadelphia Abduction, Shooting

U.S. Marshals and Newington police arrested Olukayode Taiwo, 26, Thursday at an apartment complex in Newington, Connecticut, ending a multi-state search tied to a gunpoint abduction and a later shooting in Philadelphia.

Authorities allege Taiwo abducted a woman at gunpoint on Nov. 2 at a home on the 1500 block of West Seybert Street, then returned to fire shots near her home on Rugby Street on Nov. 15.

The timeline: two incidents, thirteen days apart

Police say the abduction unfolded around 10 p.m. on Nov. 2. Taiwo forced the woman from the West Seybert Street address at gunpoint, though investigators have not disclosed how long she was held or the circumstances of her release. Thirteen days later, on Nov. 15, gunfire erupted near her residence on Rugby Street. Ballistics and witness accounts linked Taiwo to the shooting, prompting a warrant that stretched into New England.

Authorities treat any incident where a suspect returns to a victim’s neighborhood as an immediate escalation, and the fugitive task force takes the lead in such cases.

RNB Philly, citing Fox 59, adds that authorities had been actively searching for Taiwo before locating him in Connecticut. Neither source reports a motive, and police have not disclosed whether Taiwo and the woman knew each other prior to Nov. 2.

Olukayode Taiwo Arrested in Connecticut for Philadelphia Abduction, Shooting
Photo: rnbphilly.com

Custody and what comes next

Taiwo is being held in Connecticut on a $1 million bond on a charge of extradition arrest/fugitive from justice. He was scheduled to appear in New Britain Superior Court on Friday, Nov. 20. Philadelphia prosecutors will seek his return to face charges stemming from the abduction and the shooting, though the specific counts have not been publicly enumerated.

Newington, where Taiwo was arrested, lies 8 miles south of Hartford in the Capitol Planning Region and had a population of 30,527 in 2023. The town is home to Mill Pond Falls, celebrated each fall at the Waterfall Festival, and the national headquarters of the American Radio Relay League under call sign W1AW.

Settled in 1636 as “West Farms” by Wethersfield families, it was named Newington in 1721 — meaning “the new town in the meadow” — but did not incorporate until July 10, 1871, after Wethersfield refused to fund highway improvements to the railroad. The Connecticut Department of Transportation is also headquartered there.

The investigation remains open. Detectives continue to piece together the relationship between the suspect and the victim, the reason for the two-week gap, and whether any other incidents are connected.