Pennsylvania Couple Files Second Lawsuit Over Mississippi River Cruise Ship Collision

A Pennsylvania couple who barely escaped the sinking American Heritage filed the second lawsuit in Orleans Parish Civil District Court on Friday, joining two NOPD officers already suing the tanker’s owner and manager over the Nov. 13 collision at the Thalia Street Terminal.

Jay and Elizabeth Clymer sustained multiple serious injuries during the crash and the frantic rescue that followed, according to their attorneys Rico Alvendia, Anthony Irpino, Walter Leger and Pennsylvania counsel Robert Moran. “Passenger Elizabeth Clymer actually responded heroically to a medical emergency of a fellow passenger earlier in their river cruise only to face the catastrophic boat collision wherein she herself was seriously injured,” Alvendia said.

The couple, described by Moran as elderly, “barely escaped going into the frigid water only moments before the liner sank into the Mississippi River.” They remain under close medical care in Pennsylvania, their lawyers told Fox 8 Live.

Pennsylvania Couple Files Second Lawsuit Over Mississippi River Cruise Ship Collision
Photo: fox8live.com

The filing mirrors the complaint lodged Nov. 18 by officers Cedric Davillier and Regina Williams, who say they were hurt evacuating passengers and crew. Both suits name Nave Shipping SA, identified as the owner of the tanker Atlantic Asphalt, and Thome Ship Management Pte Ltd., the vessel’s manager.

The plaintiffs allege the tanker was unseaworthy, its crew improperly trained, and that the defendants failed to account for river conditions or take steps to avoid the collision. The officers are seeking punitive damages under maritime law alongside compensation for physical and emotional pain, medical expenses, lost wages and loss of enjoyment of life, WDSU reported.

The Port of New Orleans moved first in federal court, securing a $1 million maritime property damage claim and an arrest warrant for the Atlantic Asphalt. A federal judge granted the warrant, effectively freezing the tanker in port until the owner posts a bond or other financial security.

“Typically, what happens is once the vessel is seized, the owner comes to court, posts a bond in lieu of the vessel. Then the vessel can go on its way, while the bond will stand as essentially the rest that could be used to satisfy any judgments against the vessel,” experts explained to WDSU. Lawyers cautioned the litigation could take years to resolve.

Unified Command — the Coast Guard and American Cruise Lines — began lightering operations Tuesday, removing fuel from the wreck. A safety zone remains in effect between mile markers 95.5 and 96.5, extending 500 feet from the east bank.

The alternate channel is closed; limited two-way traffic is allowed through the main span, though deep-draft vessels and tows with ten or more barges are restricted to one-way transit. The NTSB continues to lead the investigation and has asked anyone with photos or video to submit them to [email protected].

The state-court suits seek jury trials and punitive damages; the federal action secures the asset. Together they frame a three-front legal battle over a single collision — passengers, first responders, and the port itself all chasing accountability from the same corporate defendants. The allegations have not been proven in court.