Pennsylvania AG Dave Sunday, 21 States Urge STB to Reject Proposed UP-NS Merger

Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday joined a bipartisan coalition of 21 attorneys general Wednesday urging the federal Surface Transportation Board to block an $85 billion merger that would hand Union Pacific control of 40 percent of the nation’s rail freight traffic, PA Office of Attorney General reported.

The filing lands as the STB weighs whether the combination of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern meets the legal standard of delivering “substantial and demonstrable public benefits” that cannot be achieved otherwise. States lack independent authority to challenge railroad mergers in court, leaving the STB as the sole gatekeeper.

“Our Commonwealth relies every day on rail lines to commute to work, visit friends and family, and transport goods, so when a major rail provider merges with another, that means one less major competitor in the market,” Sunday said. “We will be urging the Feds to look and learn from past examples and the ensuing fallout.”

Pennsylvania operates 65 freight railroads — more than any other state — and maintains 5,600 miles of track, the third-highest total nationally. The coalition argues that past Class I consolidations have consistently led to higher shipping rates, thinner workforces, and degraded service, a pattern they say the applicants have not convincingly rebutted.

Eight U.S. senators, including Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York, sent a parallel letter to the STB the same day warning that further consolidation would leave farmers, manufacturers, and small businesses with fewer shipping options and less power to negotiate fair rates, Daily Voice reported.

The senators’ letter spotlights a March comment by Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena, who suggested raising rates an additional 3 percent to 4 percent for customers who opposed the merger. Vena and the railroad have characterized the remark as a joke, but the senators told the STB it deserves scrutiny because shippers may fear retaliation if they participate candidly in the proceeding.

Union Pacific Executive Vice President Kenny Rocker pushed back in a letter to customers, writing that the railroad would not retaliate and encourages “an open, honest exchange of views on all matters, including the merger.”

The SMART Transportation Division, the nation’s largest rail labor union, has warned the deal could accelerate job cuts and make freight deliveries less reliable. The attorneys general also flag risks to short-line railroads that depend on interchange traffic with the major carriers.

The railroads announced the agreement in July 2025, projecting that a combined network spanning more than 50,000 miles across 43 states and connecting nearly 100 ports would preserve union jobs, boost competition, and reduce delays by cutting inter-line transfers. They expect the transaction to close in the second half of 2027 if approved.

Sunday, a Harrisburg native who enlisted in the Navy after high school and deployed to the Persian Gulf during Operation Desert Strike, returned to Pennsylvania to build a career as a prosecutor in York County.

He served as a special assistant U.S. attorney for the Middle District, where he led the multi-jurisdictional Operation Sunrise prosecution of more than 100 Latin Kings members, before winning election as district attorney in 2017 and then as attorney general in 2024.

The STB’s environmental review and evidentiary record remain open.