Michigan Supreme Court Proposes Rule 2.118 Amendment; Adopts Four Rule Changes Effective January 2027

The Michigan Supreme Court is weighing a rewrite of how lawsuits correct their aim, proposing changes to Rule 2.118 that would explicitly allow plaintiffs to be swapped or misnamed defendants to be fixed after the statute of limitations has run — provided the original complaint gave fair notice of the conduct at issue.

The court published the proposal November 20, opening a public comment period that runs through January 1, 2027, and a public hearing will follow. At the same time, the justices adopted four other rule amendments effective January 1, 2027, touching child protective proceedings, minor personal protection orders, alternative dispute resolution and criminal sentencing.

The relation-back rewrite

Under the current Rule 2.118(D), an amendment adding a claim or defense relates back if it arises from the same conduct, transaction or occurrence as the original pleading. The proposed amendment adds two new subsections: one governing substitution of a plaintiff and another governing correction of a defendant’s name or identity.

A substituted plaintiff would relate back if that plaintiff shares an identity of interest with the original plaintiff, asserts the same claim, and the defense is not prejudiced.

A change to the party against whom a claim is asserted would relate back only if the claim arises from the same conduct, the new party received notice within the period provided by MCR 2.102(D) so it is not prejudiced, and that party knew or should have known the action would have been brought against it but for a mistake concerning the proper party’s identity.

The staff comment accompanying the proposal notes the amendment would “clarify that the rule does not necessarily preclude relation-back of a pleading amendment to substitute a plaintiff or correct a misnomer.”

Judge a kathleen mcneilly

Amendments require findings on record and allow dismissal motions

Adopted amendments to MCR 3.972 require courts in bench trials to state findings of fact and conclusions of law on the record or in a written opinion. The rule also creates a mechanism for a respondent to move for the equivalent of an involuntary dismissal at the close of the petitioner’s case-in-chief. If all other parties request to present evidence, the court must deny the motion and proceed.

A lawyer-guardian ad litem for the child may now make a recommendation to the finder of fact regarding whether statutory grounds alleged in the petition have been proven.

Minor personal protection orders: appeal rights

Under amended MCR 3.981, courts must advise respondents of their appellate rights following the issuance of any appealable order. Appointment of appellate counsel is governed by MCR 3.993(D)(5). The staff comment says the change “requires the court to advise minor PPO respondents of their right to appeal.”

Michigan Supreme Court Proposes Rule 2.118 Amendment; Adopts Four Rule Changes Effective January 2027

ADR by videoconference

Amended MCR 2.410 explicitly allows alternative dispute resolution proceedings to be conducted by videoconferencing technology when participation is appropriate under MCR 2.407. Such proceedings need not be recorded and are not subject to public access.

Defense counsel at presentence interviews

Amended MCR 6.610(G) requires that defense counsel receive notice and a reasonable opportunity to attend any presentence interview of their client conducted as part of a court-ordered presentence investigation.

Administrative appointments

The court also announced appointments to the Commission on Well-Being in the Law: Linda Harrison and Angela Wine for terms expiring December 31, 2026; Shanice Dennis and Judge Kathleen A. Feeney for terms expiring December 31, 2027. Judge Kathleen M. McCarthy is assigned as a business court judge in the 3rd Circuit Court through April 1, 2031. Judge David J. Zelenak is appointed chief judge of the 25th District Court for 2027.

The Michigan Supreme Court traces its origins to the Supreme Court of Michigan Territory, established in 1805 with three justices serving indefinite terms. It was the only court created by the first state constitution in 1835, beginning with three members who rode circuit in Detroit, Ann Arbor and Kalamazoo.

Today the seven justices are elected to eight-year terms on a nonpartisan ballot after party nomination. They must be licensed Michigan attorneys for at least five years and under 70 at the time of election.

Every two years the justices elect one of their number as chief justice. The court also exercises broad superintending control over all state trial courts and administers the public comment process for rule changes such as the proposed amendment to Rule 2.118.

Written comments on the Rule 2.118 proposal may be submitted through the court’s website, by email to [email protected] referencing ADM File No. 2022-43, or by mail to P.O. Box 30052, Lansing, MI 48909.