Pennsylvania Board Rejects Lower Advanced Test Score Proposal, Delaying Results

The Pennsylvania State Board of Education voted 9-5 Thursday to reject a Department of Education proposal that would have lowered the score needed for students to earn an “advanced” rating on statewide exams, a decision that leaves roughly 900,000 students and their districts waiting longer for results that were already months overdue.

The vote, first reported by Chalkbeat, came after a two-week scramble that saw board members accuse the administration of rushing a major policy shift without adequate public notice.

Deputy Secretary Amy Lena told the board the rejection means the department must now re-run the spring tests under the old scoring system, a process that will take “a little bit of time,” pushing the release of official PSSA and Keystone scores deeper into the academic year.

The Communication Breakdown

State Sen. Lindsey Williams, the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee and a board member, said she and other members had no idea the department was pursuing changes until a briefing earlier this month.

“There were communication breakdowns that happened at multiple points in the process.”

“I’m not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward.”

Williams told the board. Over 800,000 students in grades 3-8 and high school take the PSSAs and Keystone exams annually, making the scoring baseline a high-stakes benchmark.

Pennsylvania Board Rejects Lower Advanced Test Score Proposal, Delaying Results
Photo: inquirer.com

The Case for Change

House Education Committee Chair Peter Schweyer was the lone legislator on the board to vote in favor. He acknowledged the timing was imperfect but argued the update was long overdue; cut scores for math and reading had not been recalibrated since 2015.

“We’ve gone way too long for addressing these (cut scores) in any kind of systematic or thoughtful manner.”

Schweyer said. Department officials, including Bureau of Curriculum, Assessment and Instruction Director Brian Campbell, argued the new thresholds — developed by a panel of 90 educators — would better align performance labels with what students actually know and provide teachers with more precise descriptors for lesson planning. The change would not have altered proficiency cutoffs, only the “advanced” designation.

Philadelphia’s Selection Crisis Deepens

The delay hits Philadelphia hardest. The district has already twice postponed its school selection deadline for competitive magnet schools, which require minimum PSSA scores for admission. Families currently have until Dec. 16 to apply, but the district planned to shut down the selection portal from Nov. 24 to Dec. 2 to upload score data — data the state now cannot provide on schedule.

Philly school students
Photo: penncapital-star.com

Superintendent Tony Watlington has ruled out going “test optional” for magnet admissions. A district spokesperson did not respond to Chalkbeat’s request for comment on whether the latest state delay will force a third schedule change.

Standards vs. Inflation

The proposal drew sharp opposition from advocacy groups. Mark Gleason, managing partner of The Drexel Fund and former director of the Philadelphia School Partnership, testified before the board that lowering the advanced threshold amounted to watering down standards.

“This is the national trend,” Gleason told the board. “I don’t think it’s what we want Pennsylvania to be participating in.”

The Pennsylvania State Board of Education, created by the General Assembly in 1963 and reestablished in 1988, comprises 21 members who also serve as the State Board of Career and Technical Education.

Seventeen members are appointed by the Governor with Senate confirmation for six-year terms, while four are sitting legislators holding leadership roles on the House and Senate Education Committees. The Board meets at least six times annually and holds the authority to adopt regulations governing educational standards and to approve or disapprove changes to school district boundaries.

Delays Leave Districts and Families in Limbo

Board Vice Chair Carol Aichele, who voted for the proposal, stressed the practical stakes: "The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we're almost halfway through the current year." With no new timeline for the re-scored results, districts, teachers, and Philadelphia families dealing with the magnet lottery remain in limbo.