Portland families learned Tuesday that a plan to close 10 elementary schools would cut more teaching positions than keeping every building open, a contradiction that has become the sharpest evidence yet that the district’s math does not add up.
Software engineer and Irvington parent Alexis Córdova traced the numbers in Superintendent Kimberlee Armstrong’s memo to the board and found that the status quo would eliminate roughly 260 full-time positions, while the closure plan would cut more than 300, opb reported.
“There will literally be less FTE to go around for everybody even though they’re saying that it is going to be better,” Córdova said. The district’s senior director of data and accountability, Richard Smith, countered that the gap of about 40 positions would be “re-invested” across the 19 receiving schools, though the memo shows only 15 to 20 staff spread that thin.
The revelation landed hours before a packed board meeting at the Dr. Matthew Prophet Education Center and one day before the Portland Association of Teachers president, Alisha Chavez, told OPB’s “Think Out Loud” that the district still lacks an adequate plan.
“We still don’t know what staffing’s gonna look like, transportation, the supports for our students who have [individual education programs],” Chavez said. Parents and the union are now pressing the board to pause a process they say has been broken from the start.

Enrollment forecasts sit at the center of the dispute. Portland State University’s Population Research Center, which supplies the district’s projections, reports districtwide errors under 2 percent over five years, but Ethan Sharygin, the center’s director, acknowledged that individual school errors can swing to 10 percent.
McKay Larrabee, a Sunnyside parent who has studied the methodology, told KATU the recommendation relies on data more than a year and a half old. “We’re making irreversible decisions based on outdated numbers when current numbers are available,” Larrabee said. The state’s latest revenue forecast projects a further decline of 69,500 students, or 12.9 percent, over the next decade.
Receiving schools face immediate crowding
Under Armstrong’s recommendation, 19 schools would absorb displaced students, and several would exceed functional capacity on day one. Parents from Beach, Sitton and James John elementary schools warned in a Monday letter that Chief Joseph Elementary, set to receive Beach students, will be too full to house specialized rooms for speech, therapy and de-escalation.
Martin Luther King Jr. Elementary in Northeast Portland is projected at 572 students against a functional capacity of 584 after absorbing Sabin Elementary, leaving no margin for growth.
At the same time, James John and Sitton are forecast to fall below 260 students each, and three middle schools would dip under 400. The district defines a sustainable K‑5 as at least 360 students and a sustainable middle school as 500.
Even after closures, only half of K‑5s and 47 percent of middle schools would meet that threshold, up from 18 and 13 percent today. “The recommendation puts PPS on the path to sustainability, but it won’t get there with this plan,” Smith said.

Safety and language program concerns impact students
Board member Stephanie Engelsman raised a concrete safety issue Tuesday night: deaf and hard-of-hearing students from Creston would move to Glencoe Elementary, which lacks an elevator, while their Creston peers go to Atkinson. “We need a walk-through of that building before we vote on this,” Engelsman said.
Meanwhile, Virginia La Forte plans amendments to the proposed Spanish dual-language hub system, which would reduce sites from eight to three across east Portland. She told The Oregonian she has requested transportation timetables and worries some children could face hour-long rides.
Parents at Rose City Park flagged a classroom mismatch for the Vietnamese dual-language program slated for Vestal Elementary. “The Vietnamese dual language immersion program needs 12 classrooms, one English and one Vietnamese teacher for each grade,” parent Emma Meyers told the board.
“We understand that facilities told Vestal that we only needed six, which is all they have available. That means up to 52 students per classroom. It does not add up.” District officials did not respond to the testimony during the meeting.
Board amendments due by November 30
Board chair Eddie Wang gave members until November 30 to file amendments, with a discussion session set for December 1 and a possible Teaching, Learning, and Enrollment committee meeting on December 2.
Christy Splitt has signaled she will revive elements of her earlier “Scenario D,” which closed only six schools and delayed magnet entry to second grade. The final vote remains scheduled for December 15. If approved, the district would spend January through March building school-specific transition plans, followed by months of implementation.
“This school closure process has been broken from the beginning and we are now doing what PPS should have done from the start. Building trust and relationships with each other, pooling our wisdom, pulling from each other’s experiences and standing together to fight for the schools our students, our families, our communities, Portland, and Oregon deserve,”
Armstrong previously served as the district’s Chief Academic Officer before leaving for the Evergreen School District in Vancouver, Wash., where she was Deputy Superintendent.
Her career began as a teacher in the Puyallup School District in Washington and includes leadership roles in California, where she was principal of Mount Miguel High School and Associate Superintendent of Santa Rosa City Schools. She holds a Doctor of Education from the University of Washington and is the author of a book on intersectional leadership and equity.
At a Thursday listening session at Franklin High School, students will have their first formal chance to address the board before the December 15 vote.