Providence City Council voted 10 to 4 Thursday to ban automated license plate readers, ordering the immediate deactivation of the city’s Flock camera network and the termination of its contracts with the company.
The ordinance prohibits any city agency from operating ALPRs or accessing their data — including data from outside owners such as the Rhode Island State Police — and requires the return of all equipment. It passed over the objections of Mayor Brett Smiley and Police Chief Oscar Perez, who argued the technology was instrumental in solving serious crimes, including the identification of the suspect in the December 13 mass shooting near Brown University.
“I think we’re being given a false choice between safety and civil liberties,” Councilor Sue AnderBois told colleagues during the hearing. “The real safety concerns for our neighbors that we witness every day come from ALPR cameras.”
“We appreciate the City Council’s thoughtful consideration of this ordinance and recognize the importance of balancing privacy, accountability and public safety,” Chief Perez said in a statement shared with The Herald. “At the same time, ALPR technology has become an important investigative tool for our detectives, helping identify vehicles, develop leads and solve serious crimes.”
The vote caps months of escalating pressure. In October, Governor Dan McKee paused all ALPR installations statewide to give legislators time to draft regulations. Over 100 cities nationwide and at least five Rhode Island towns have already ended their Flock contracts. Mayor-elect David Morales, who takes office in January, campaigned on canceling the deal.

A Rhode Island College student report presented to the council in May found that organizations not listed on Providence’s Flock Transparency Portal accessed the city’s camera data more than 3.2 million times between November 2024 and November 2025, spanning over 1,400 jurisdictions. The ordinance cites that finding alongside allegations of ICE using Flock data “to kidnap immigrant neighbors,” authorized users stalking partners and ex-partners, and repeated misidentification of vehicles and individuals.
Flock’s own transparency portal lists 60 cameras in Providence. The ordinance puts the actual number above 100, counting cameras operated under a separate State Police contract. Neither the city nor State Police responded to requests for comment on the discrepancy.
The three-year contract, signed in October 2023, costs between $155,000 and $170,000 annually and was not set to expire until May 2027. Council President Rachel Miller, AnderBois, and Councilman Miguel Sanchez sponsored the measure. Sanchez, who is poised to become the next council president, said the council has the votes to sustain the ban after committee review.
“There’s been communications with the chief’s office throughout this process,” Sanchez told The Journal, disputing Perez’s claim that he was not consulted before the ordinance was drafted. “We want to protect every Providence resident’s civil liberties.”
Smiley, in a statement to The Journal, maintained that “LPRs are a proven tool used for public safety that has helped our police officers identify suspects, locate vehicles, solve serious crimes and keep our neighborhoods safe,” adding that the city should focus on “additional protections and guardrails” rather than elimination.
A Flock spokesperson emailed The Herald: “We support strong privacy safeguards and local oversight, but communities should not have to choose between protecting privacy and giving law enforcement the tools they need to solve serious crimes, find missing people and keep people safe.” ICE did not respond to a request for comment.
Flock Safety, founded in 2017 by three Georgia Tech alumni who built their first cameras by hand around a dining room table, now operates automated license plate readers in over 6,000 communities across all 50 states.
The company, which joined Y Combinator in Summer 2017, performs more than 20 billion vehicle scans monthly in the U.S. A June 2024 ruling in Norfolk, Virginia, found that warrantless collection of location data from Flock ALPRs constitutes a Fourth Amendment search, prompting legal pushback in other jurisdictions.
Flock has also faced scrutiny over its data being used for immigration enforcement, and in October 2026 announced an 18% staff reduction following a voluntary buyout program.
The ordinance takes effect immediately upon passage, requiring the city to discontinue use and terminate agreements without waiting for the contract’s 2027 expiration.
- U.S. Army to Detonate 68 Drums of Lead Azide at Iowa Plant Monday
- Virginia Tech Men’s Soccer Signs Seven Players to 2027 Roster
- What Trump's Housing Order Means for a $360,000 Loan at 7.32% (daybreakwire.com)
- Olivia Chow Reshapes Toronto Council, Appoints Erskine-Smith, Layton to Key Committees (archyde.com)