Recount Leaves South Dakota Senate District 11 Result Unchanged

Democrat Aaron Matson asked for a recount in South Dakota’s District 11 Senate race; the tally came back identical Thursday, News From The States reported.

The Minnehaha County Auditor’s Office confirmed the results were unchanged after a recount board appointed by a local judge reviewed the ballots. Republican incumbent Chris Karr, the chamber’s president pro tempore, defeated Matson by 35 votes out of 8,385 cast — a margin of roughly four-tenths of one percent.

South Dakota law allows a recount when the gap does not exceed 2% of the total votes in a Senate race. Five legislative contests fell within that threshold after the Nov. 3 election, but Matson was the only candidate to petition for one. The deadline to file was three days after the state canvass, which took place Tuesday, South Dakota Searchlight reported.

Recount Leaves South Dakota Senate District 11 Result Unchanged
Photo: southdakotasearchlight.com

“Making up for a 129-vote deficit ‘is not even in the realm of possibility, from my standpoint,'”

Republican Rep. Keri Weems said of her own House race in the same district, explaining why she declined to request a recount, South Dakota Searchlight reported.

The recount board consisted of a Republican attorney serving as referee and one member each from the Republican and Democratic parties. The process had to be completed within 14 days of the petition filing.

With the Senate result settled, the partisan split for the 2025 legislative session stands at 92 Republicans, 12 Democrats and one independent. Democrats gained seats in the Legislature this cycle for the first time since 2008, though the District 11 pickup they hoped for did not materialize.

Recount Leaves South Dakota Senate District 11 Result Unchanged
Photo: yahoo.com
Race Leader Trailer Vote margin
District 11 Senate Chris Karr (R) Aaron Matson (D) 35
District 11 House Brian Mulder (R) Keri Weems (R) 129
District 12 Senate Kari Shanard-Koenders (R) Joe Zweifel (D) 134
District 3 House Timothy Hanigan (R) Erin Ronayne Rudner (D) 143
District 9 House Megan Tschetter (R) Amanda Potter (D) 157

Erin Ronayne Rudner, the District 3 House candidate, told Searchlight she might have considered a recount if her Aberdeen-area race were as close as Matson’s, but the 143-vote gap was “a big chasm to leap.” She added, “I have faith in our Brown County Auditor’s Office to do their jobs right.”

Chris Karr, a native of Tabor, South Dakota, earned a bachelor’s degree in business economics from South Dakota State University and an MBA from the University of South Dakota. He was first elected to the House in 2016, chaired the House Appropriations Committee from 2019 to 2022, and served as a majority whip before winning the Senate seat in 2024.

Official results are posted by the Secretary of State at electionresults.sd.gov.