“It’s the most searing takedown of a public body I’ve ever seen from the AG’s office,” said John Marion, executive director for Common Cause Rhode Island, reacting to a 13-page letter sent Monday that puts the city of Woonsocket on formal notice of a Superior Court lawsuit for “willfully and knowingly” violating the state’s Access to Public Records Act.
The letter, obtained by Rhode Island Current, documents at least 27 failures over the last three years to fulfill public records requests on time — or at all — marking the third time in eight years Attorney General Peter Neronha has pursued legal action against a public body for APRA violations.
Special Assistant Attorney General Patrick Reynolds wrote that the city violated the law “in virtually the same manner” repeatedly and “largely refused to remedy its error unless and until this Office directed it to do so,” calling it a “pattern of systemic failure” and rejecting the “same tired excuse” of staffing shortages.
The stakes are straightforward: the 1979 law gives public bodies 10 business days to provide records, with a 20-day extension for complex requests. Woonsocket routinely missed both windows, often ignoring requests for months until an appeal forced a response, and in several cases records dating back years remain wholly unfilled.
The requests came from residents, lawyers, landlords, and even the former city council president, seeking employee salaries, city contracts, and tax data — information the public is legally entitled to see.
This is not a new problem. In 2009, then-Attorney General Patrick Lynch sued over a 2008 request from the Woonsocket Fire Fighters Association that went unanswered for six months; the city paid a $1,000 fine under a consent judgment in 2010. In 2013, the AG’s office filed another complaint over a nearly 10-month delay for a private attorney’s request.
As recently as 2022 and 2023, a reporter for The Public’s Radio — now Ocean State Media — waited on four requests until the AG’s office threatened court action and a $1,000 fine. “This finding should have marked the end of the City’s practice of blatantly ignoring APRA requests,” Reynolds wrote, “but instead it sadly marked only the beginning of the City’s misadventure.”

The city’s legal apparatus has contracted rather than expanded. Since late 2022, City Solicitor Michael Lepizzera and Allan Fung — brought on in early 2024 — have handled all city legal matters alongside their private practices. The city no longer employs the two attorneys who previously managed records requests. Reynolds called the decision not to use clerks or non-legal staff “deliberate,” amounting to a “willful and knowing or reckless” violation.
He also flagged a structural flaw: no clear pathway exists for requests to reach Lepizzera and Fung directly, forcing the AG’s appeal process to serve as the city’s de facto notification system — a burden on the state office and a denial of prompt access for the public.
Mayor Christopher Beauchamp did not respond to requests for comment Tuesday. Mayor-elect Dan Gendron, the sitting council president who defeated Beauchamp in November, acknowledged the letter and said his administration plans “a more detailed recording of APRA requests to make sure they are answered in a timely fashion. Obviously, there appears to be some breakdown somewhere.”
The human cost appears in the letter’s recipients. Gregory Rice, a landlord and developer with Nexus Property Management, filed three requests between January and September seeking tax records for properties comparable to a church on Orlo Street his company converted to luxury apartments.
As of Tuesday, he had received nothing. The records would help challenge what he calls an unfair property valuation; his company sued the city over the assessment anyway. “The city is extremely sloppy, inefficient and understaffed,” Rice said, calling the pending lawsuit a “monumental step forward.”
John Ward, a former city council president who ran for mayor in 2024, had three requests from May 2025 to October 2026 left unanswered for more than 10 days. “Frankly, very, very simple requests were being ignored for days and weeks at a time,” Ward said.
He used the law to retrieve information he lost access to after leaving the council, often prompted by resident complaints on social media. “It’s a situation that didn’t have to happen,” he said, noting the worsening financial outlook as the city moves to close its regional wastewater treatment plant.
Good-government advocates argue the problem is cultural, not statutory. “At a certain point, over so many years, dozens of violations, it’s inescapable that the city just doesn’t prioritize transparency,” Marion said. He has long pushed to overhaul the APRA, last updated in 2012, which he says offers loopholes for agencies to deny or overcharge for records.
But he doubted a legislative fix would compel a routine law-breaker like Woonsocket. “This is really the biggest hammer in the toolbox of the AG’s office when it comes to enforcing the law,” Marion said of civil litigation.
Neronha’s office previously sued Pawtucket and West Warwick for APRA violations in 2020 and 2019, respectively, and took the Woonsocket City Council to court in 2019 for violating the Open Meetings Act over vague agendas — a case settled with a $5,000 fine. The Pawtucket case was dismissed after the legislature exempted the requested records — police officers’ addresses — from disclosure. West Warwick settled, though the agreement is not public.
There is no timeline for filing the complaint. Neronha, term-limited, leaves office in early January. Attorney General-elect Kim Ahern did not respond to requests for comment.