Richmond Judge Weighs Due Process in Rocovich Suit Against Gov. Spanberger

“That doesn’t change anything about [the] due process clause,” Thomas McCarthy told the court Wednesday, arguing that his client’s board seat is property the state cannot take without a hearing.

A Richmond judge said he expects to rule after Thanksgiving on pretrial motions in the lawsuit former Virginia Tech rector John Rocovich filed against Gov. Abigail Spanberger and the university, Cardinal News reported. Substitute Judge Michael McKenney heard arguments Wednesday in Richmond Circuit Court over whether the governor’s removal of Rocovich from the Board of Visitors in May violated state law and the constitution.

The case tests whether a gubernatorial appointment to a public university board carries due-process protections, or whether the governor serves as the “sole judge” of removal decisions as state law declares. The ruling could clarify removal standards for appointees across Virginia’s public universities.

Rocovich, a Roanoke attorney who served as rector, was removed in May for what Spanberger described as violations of the board’s code of ethics. The removal letter did not specify the alleged violations, and the governor’s office has not detailed them since. Spanberger appointed Edward Baine, president of Dominion Energy, to fill the seat. Baine and another appointee, Sharon Brickhouse Martin, are also named in the suit.

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a classical stone government building facade with a single flagpole, in deep
Photo: wisevoter.com

The lawsuit was filed in Montgomery County in June and later moved to Richmond.

McCarthy argued that state law permits removal only for “malfeasance, misfeasance, incompetence or gross neglect of duty,” and that the statute’s grant of property — the board seat — triggers due-process protections even though the same law calls the governor the “sole judge” of the reasoning. The lack of judicial review, he contended, violates the separation of powers by stripping courts of the power to hold the governor accountable.

Michael Shebelskie of Hunton Andrews Kurth, representing Spanberger, countered that the General Assembly wrote the law allowing the governor to appoint and remove board members and to be the “sole judge” of the decision. “This is a political dispute between the General Assembly and the governor,” Shebelskie said.

Cullen Seltzer of Sands Anderson, representing Virginia Tech and the board members, supported Shebelskie’s arguments and added that McCarthy’s position cannot be based on reading part of the statute while ignoring the rest. “All of those actions were the governor’s actions,” Seltzer said, emphasizing that the challenged decisions did not originate from the school or its board.

Judge McKenney questioned whether Rocovich’s gubernatorial appointment constitutes property in the same way as a public employee’s livelihood. Part of the case law McCarthy cited involved a public school security guard who was fired, losing pay and the ability to earn a living. “Explain that to me,” the judge said, prompting McCarthy to argue that it didn’t matter whether the position in question was paid or unpaid.

Rocovich, born in Roanoke in 1945, first served on the Board of Visitors from 1997 to 2005 and was rector from 2002 to 2004 before returning for a second term in 2010. A Virginia Tech graduate who earned a law degree from the University of Richmond and a master’s in taxation from New York University, he established the Roanoke firm Moss & Rocovich.

In 1986 he orchestrated a $4.7 million gift to create the Harvey W. Peters Research Center for Parkinson’s disease, an endowment that has grown to $11.5 million, and the following year arranged two $5 million gifts endowing engineering departments that fund dozens of scholarships annually. He also founded the Edward Via College of Osteopathic Medicine in Blacksburg and serves as chairman of its board.

Attorneys for Spanberger and Virginia Tech argued that a decision would be premature since McKenney could rule to throw out the case on the motions, while direct arguments on the merits of the case haven’t been made yet.

The judge did not make a clear indication as to which side he favored during the hearing. Rocovich sat in a front row of the courtroom but did not speak and declined to provide any comment to Cardinal News afterward. A spokesperson for the governor’s office could not be reached for comment Wednesday night.