Residents Oppose Housing on Former Magdalene Laundry Site; Nuns Cite Scale

“It is incumbent on Dublin City Council to ensure the integrity of the site is preserved,” a coalition of local residents wrote in their appeal to An Coimisiún Pleanála, “given the alteration of the social climate in recent years and the acknowledgment of abuses suffered by women who resided in these laundries/asylums.”

The council granted Pembroke Partnership planning permission last month for 34 apartments, duplexes and town houses on the grounds of the former Donnybrook Magdalene laundry in Dublin 4, a decision now under formal appeal.

The Religious Sisters of Charity, who operated the laundry for more than a century until its closure in 1992, have separately raised “excessive scale” concerns through their agents, Avison Young, citing overlooking and loss of daylight at the adjoining St Mary’s convent where more than 25 sisters still live.

Neither the order’s planning observations nor its public statement to The Irish Times referenced the laundry’s history; the residents’ appeal centers on it.

A site of State and Church history

According to the Government’s 2013 McAleese report, an official inquiry into the State’s involvement with Magdalene laundries, the laundry accommodated between 100 and 120 women and girls “over much of the period of its operation” between 1883 and 1992.

The Justice for Magdalenes Research group believes up to 315 women and girls died on the site. The McAleese report found the State relied heavily on religious congregations to provide services for women and girls referred by families, psychiatric services, courts and other institutions.

Up to 315 women and girls are believed to have died at the site of the Donnybrook Magdalene laundry
Photo: irishtimes-irishtimes-staging.cdn.arcpublishing.com

Pembroke Partnership’s proposal includes three apartment blocks up to six storeys high, partial demolition and refurbishment of the existing laundry building, and a “post-and-panel-style information sign” at the base of the 90-metre chimney, a protected structure since 2012. Construction plans submitted with the application appeared to place the memorial partly behind a bin, though the developers’ urban planners later clarified it would be publicly accessible, The Irish Times reported.

Two appeals, different grounds

“The social, cultural and historical significance of this site demands that Dublin City Council seek an alternative approach to planning how this site, a former Magdalene asylum, is developed and used in a more appropriate and respectful manner; one which is sensitive to the community of survivors who experienced abuse and neglect in this setting.”

the five objectors, all living on the same road as the former laundry, wrote in their submission to An Coimisiún Pleanála. They also argue the scheme constitutes overdevelopment without adequate infrastructure, describing recent local development as “haphazard and piecemeal.”

The nuns’ agents took a different tack. In a letter dated November 20, 2025, Avison Young told the council the height presented “a significant protrusion” above existing buildings and flagged “a significant opportunity for overlooking” the convent’s courtyard and residences. A second letter, dated July 7, 2026, said no “material” or “significant” design change had been made since November and that revised plans resulted in “more acute” overlooking, a risk that “materially increased” with architectural changes.

“Any loss of light for these residents is unacceptable,” the firm wrote. The letters also cited construction noise, lack of car parking, and risk to the “private amenity of the convent” where hundreds of sisters are buried, including foundress Mother Mary Aikenhead.

A meeting was held “in good faith” with Pembroke Partnership in May 2026, the July letter noted, during which the order’s observations “were set out in detail” and a commitment was made to explore design changes. “Unfortunately, no further information was received,” the letter continued.

Recognition without commemoration?

In its statement to The Irish Times, the Religious Sisters of Charity acknowledged that “the Church, the State and wider society played roles in the exclusion and institutionalisation of women who were vulnerable or marginalised” and that “practices and standards of the past must be considered in the context of what is expected and accepted in Irish society today.”

The order said its understanding throughout the planning process was that the developers intended to commemorate the former use of the land, and it was satisfied with that approach, so it did not raise the matter in its submission to the council.

The residents’ appeal challenges that satisfaction directly. “Dublin City Council surely cannot see fit that a structure of such sensitivity and significance should be partly demolished and the site repurposed to make way for another faceless housing development in the name of developer profit,” they wrote.

Founded by Mary Aikenhead in Dublin on 15 January 1815, the Religious Sisters of Charity were the first religious women to arrive in Australia in 1838. They opened St Vincent’s Hospital in Dublin in 1834 and, under Anna Gaynor, pioneered the modern hospice movement at Our Lady’s Hospice in Harold’s Cross from 1879.

Efforts to develop the land began at least as early as 2017, when Pembroke Partnership submitted and later withdrew a 25-unit application. The council approved 44 apartments in three- and four-storey blocks in 2020, but that project never commenced, according to council records cited by The Irish Times. An Coimisiún Pleanála is now due to rule on the current appeal.