Four Seattle residents filed tort claims this week alleging the city collected millions in “extra garbage” fees it knew were inaccurate, the first step toward a proposed class action against Seattle Public Utilities.
The claims, filed Wednesday and reported by the Seattle Times, argue that SPU’s auditing system incentivizes its contractors — Recology and Waste Management — to overreport extra garbage while shielding the city from accountability for wrongful charges. SPU billed for extra garbage more than 342,000 times last year, generating roughly $8.7 million in revenue.
“Despite alarming reporting inconsistencies, the City has continued to collect these charges,” the claim addendum says. “The City expects customers to expend their own time and resources correcting its staggeringly flawed system — one bill at a time.”
City contracts require collectors to document extra garbage left at the curb and promise periodic monitoring of random addresses to assess accuracy. Contractors earn bonuses for accuracy above 95% and face deductions below 85%.
But the claims allege the audit checks only one side of the ledger. Inspectors photograph extra garbage they find and match it against collector reports. Collectors are penalized for missing garbage the city spotted, but not for reporting garbage the city didn’t find.
“The City only audited to make sure that the contractors were reporting extra waste,” the claims say. “It did not audit to make sure the contractors accurately reported the absence of extra waste.”
Andrew Ackley, an attorney with Stritmatter Law representing the claimants, said the structure creates a perverse incentive: collectors could theoretically bill every address for extra garbage and still score 100% accuracy, because they would match every instance city inspectors documented.
The claims also argue SPU obscures the fees by folding them into combined utility bills where water and sewer charges fluctuate monthly. Extra garbage fees appear on the last page of a three-page statement, after a boilerplate page of phone numbers that signals the personalized charges are over.

Customers who spot an error can call 206-684-3000 to dispute it, but refunds only reach back two billing cycles, the claim says.
“I am happy to pay for garbage that I set out, or if someone is illegally dumping on my property, that’s my responsibility, too,” Elizabeth Forsyth, one of the four claimants, told the Seattle Times in April. “If you’ve got a photo of it, I am happy to pay for it, but I believe these are fraud.”
Forsyth, along with Patti Gorman, Karen Deyerle and Hugh Rubin, are seeking reimbursement for “unfair and unlawful charges” and a court order forcing accurate future reporting.
Both Seattle Public Utilities and the city’s finance office, which receives tort claims, declined to comment Wednesday.
Seattle, the county seat of King County where any lawsuit would be filed, grew 21.1% between 2010 and 2020, making it one of the nation’s fastest-growing large cities. The city sits on an isthmus between Puget Sound and Lake Washington, about 100 miles south of the Canadian border, and its port ranked fourth in North America for container handling as of 2021.
The tort claims give the city 60 days to respond before a lawsuit can be filed in King County Superior Court.