Sirianni Stands Pat: Mannion Keeps Play Sheet, Milton Keeps Huddle vs Steelers

Nick Sirianni emerged from the bye week with a decision that defines where the Philadelphia Eagles stand: Sean Mannion keeps the play sheet, Joe Milton keeps the huddle, and the offense keeps searching for an identity that vanished when Lane Johnson retired and Jalen Hurts was lost to blood clots.

Bleeding Green Nation reported Wednesday that the head coach considered shuffling responsibilities on his staff but ultimately stood pat, leaving Mannion — a first-year coordinator in his third season of coaching — to face a Steelers defense that ranks 15th in DVOA while Philadelphia sits 28th. The Eagles have averaged 0.8 points per offensive drive in the second half this season; no other team is worse than 1.19.

The injury report offers the only tangible hope

DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks returned to limited practice after missing multiple games, joining Will Shipley, Nolan Smith, Michael Carter, Britain Covey and Jonathan Jones on a seven-man limited list. Smith told reporters he is “100% healthy.”

Getting the top two receivers back would change the geometry of a passing attack averaging 171.7 yards per game — bottom five in the league — but it does not solve the structural issues that have produced a league-worst 35.7% three-and-out rate.

Eagles Keep Sean Mannion as Play-Caller, Joe Milton Starts vs Steelers — NFL reports

Nick Sirianni said rookie WR Makai Lemon has the ability to do multiple things and a unique skill set.

Paganetti returns to a line he knows

The most significant staff move wasn’t a demotion but a reunion. T.J. Paganetti, fired by New Orleans as run-game coordinator after the Saints’ ground game collapsed, is back in the building where he spent ten years working alongside Jeff Stoutland. He knows Jordan Mailata, Landon Dickerson and Tyler Steen.

He coached Saquon Barkley, Will Shipley and Dallas Goedert in pass protection. The Eagles’ blocking assignments have been erratic all season; Paganetti is a communicator, not a magician, but the hope is that familiarity reduces the missed assignments that have sabotaged both the run game and Milton’s pocket.

By the numbers: a offense stuck in neutral

Category Eagles Rank/Rate League Context
Red zone efficiency 3rd (73% TD) Elite
Turnover rate T-10th (9.2%) Respectable
Three-and-out % 1st (35.7%) Worst in NFL
Passing yards/game 171.7 Bottom five
Rushing yards/game 88.6 Bottom five
Points/game 16.4 Bottom five
Second-half points/drive 0.8 Worst in NFL (next worst 1.19)

The red-zone touchdown rate (73%) and turnover discipline (9.2%) are the only bright spots in an ESPN midseason audit of every offensive coordinator. Mannion was hired to install a McVay-Shanahan outside-zone system; the run game has “largely fallen flat,” and the scheme is now unrecognizable.

The context is brutal: Johnson retired, Hurts is out for the year, center Cam Jurgens was traded to Baltimore, and Barkley, Smith and Wicks have all missed chunks of the schedule.

Milton’s audition continues; the betting market sees trouble

Milton rushed for more production than he threw in his Week 9 debut. The bye buys him prep time, but the Eagles are 0-9 as home underdogs in the Sirianni era and 2-14 against the spread in the second halves of their last 16 games.

Pittsburgh’s second-half team total of -2.5 is sitting on the board; the Steelers have been a disaster in true road games, yet they couldn’t run on Cincinnati last week, and before that they led the league in rush EPA per play. Jordan Davis, one of Philadelphia’s best run-stuffing tackles, was traded before the bye.

Sirianni Stands Pat: Mannion Keeps Play Sheet, Milton Keeps Huddle vs Steelers
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

The NFC East math remains brutal

New York leads the division at 5-3-1 despite ranking 24th in DVOA — below average in all three phases. Philadelphia’s path is simpler on paper — get healthy, protect Milton, find a second-half pulse — but the offense has shown no evidence it can sustain drives against competent defenses.

The Steelers get Michael Pittman Jr. back from plantar fasciitis and Roman Wilson back from a finger injury, bolstering a passing game that has stalled over the last month. For Philadelphia, the question is no longer whether the scheme works. It’s whether the personnel returning from injury can mask the scheme’s absence long enough to steal a wild-card spot in a division where mediocrity might be enough.