South Brunswick Man Charged With Murder After Fatal Neighbor Fight at Apartment Complex

A South Brunswick man was charged with murder Saturday after a fatal fight between neighbors at the Royal Oaks Apartment complex on Friday night.

  • Altaray Cunningham, 44, died from blunt force trauma at the scene on Sugar Maple Court.
  • Jordan Williams, 28, was arrested hours later in Franklin Township after a barricade situation.
  • Williams faces first-degree murder and two weapons charges.
  • Authorities have not disclosed a motive or what led to the altercation.

Police respond to 911 call

South Brunswick officers were dispatched to Sugar Maple Court shortly after 7:30 p.m. on Nov. 20 following a 911 call reporting a physical fight. Middlesex County Prosecutor Linda Estremera said officers discovered Cunningham with blunt force trauma and pronounced him dead at the scene.

Suspect located after multi-town pursuit

Detectives identified Williams as a suspect during the initial investigation. Police located him in Woodbridge Township, where he fled from officers into Franklin Township and barricaded himself inside his vehicle, the Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office said. He was taken into custody with assistance from the Somerset County SWAT team, as well as Edison, North Brunswick, Woodbridge and Franklin Township police departments.

Charges filed Saturday

He remains in custody pending a pretrial detention hearing in Middlesex County Superior Court. Estremera did not disclose what led up to the altercation.

Photo: newjersey.news12.com

Neighbors describe witnessing violence

Residents told New Jersey 12 the confrontation was between next-door neighbors and brought people out of their homes, including children. “One of the children was looking out his window and saw what happened. I feel bad for that poor kid,” one neighbor told the station. Another described Cunningham as a “good guy” who took care of his family and worked at Trinitas Regional Medical Center in Elizabeth.

Community grieves as children witness deadly fight

Neighbors told News 12 the commotion brought residents out of their homes and many witnessed the violence between Cunningham and his next-door neighbor. “One of the children was looking out his window and saw what happened. I feel bad for that poor kid,” one neighbor said. Another resident recalled seeing the victim on the ground and said, “wow I was just talking to him a couple days ago.”

The incident left the apartment community shocked, with residents expressing grief over the sudden loss and the trauma witnessed by children.

Photo: englebrookindependentnews.com

Mayor and police chief praise response and outreach

Ryan said the township would get through the difficult time by looking out for one another.

Community response underway

Ryan, Deputy Chief Dennis Yuhasz and crisis counselors were in the neighborhood Saturday talking to residents. Teachers and counselors, including Crossroads South Middle School Principal Bonnie Capes, gave their day to be with students and families, Carley said in a statement. “When students return to class, those same caring adults will be waiting,” he said.

“South Brunswick is a strong community and we will get through this difficult time by looking out for one another and supporting those who need it most,” Ryan said.

The investigation remains active. Detectives are asking anyone with information to reach Detective Martin Halmi of the South Brunswick Police Department at (732) 329-4646 or Detective Olivia Ankudowicz of the Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office at (732) 745-8083.