Teen Charged in Girl’s Murder Claims Another Teen Told Him to Shoot

“Hey J, bust her!”

That is what a 17-year-old accused of killing a 13-year-old girl in Indianapolis told detectives another teenager instructed him to say just before a fatal shot rang out, according to court documents cited by WRTV.

Javontay Williams faces a murder charge in the Oct. 24 death of Andrea Eguia, who died after being shot inside an apartment on Bunker Hill Drive on the city’s northeast side. The case has drawn intense scrutiny as investigators parse conflicting witness statements, cellphone videos recorded minutes before the tragedy, and text messages sent in the immediate aftermath.

Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department officers arrived at the apartment at 3:59 a.m. following the shooting, finding Eguia with a gunshot wound to her abdomen, according to a probable cause affidavit noted by Yahoo News. She was transported to Methodist Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.

13-year-old Andrea Eguia killed in shooting at northeast Indianapolis apartment — WTHR

Before the shooting, Williams and three other teenagers were hanging out in the residence. Cellphone videos recovered by investigators show the group dancing, passing around a handgun, and pointing its attached light at one another. A recording from 3:55 a.m. shows Williams holding the weapon and waving it toward the camera.

A juvenile witness told detectives that Williams and Eguia were joking in the kitchen when Williams grew upset by a remark. After Williams made a threat, Eguia reportedly responded, “Then do it.”

Teen Charged in Girl's Murder Claims Another Teen Told Him to Shoot
Photo: wrtv.com

Moments later, the witness heard a gunshot. Eguia stated, “He shot me,” before collapsing on the floor, according to court records.

Following his Nov. 10 arrest on North Hamilton Avenue, Williams offered a different narrative to detectives. He claimed another teenager called him into the kitchen, uttered the instruction to shoot, and handed him the gun. Williams stated he pointed the weapon upward slightly before it discharged, adding that he did not know it was loaded and had no intention of harming Eguia.

Two teens arrested in connection to shooting an 11-year-old — WLKY News Louisville

When questioned about this claim, the juvenile witness told investigators she neither heard another teenager issue instructions nor saw anyone hand Williams the firearm immediately before the shot was fired.

Investigators also recovered text messages sent from Williams to a witness shortly after the incident. “Bro I stg I didn’t mean to do tht Ong,” he wrote at 4:38 a.m., followed seconds later by, “I didn’t kno the gun wasn’t on safe I promise I’m sorry.”

An autopsy confirmed that Eguia died from a single gunshot wound to her torso that caused massive internal bleeding, and her death was officially ruled a homicide. The Marion County Prosecutor’s Office formally filed the murder charge against Williams on Nov. 13.

Williams was scheduled to appear in Marion County court on Tuesday, Nov. 17. While a media request to cover the proceeding was approved, court records did not immediately clarify whether the hearing took place or what decisions emerged from it. The probable cause affidavit does not indicate whether the firearm has been recovered or if additional individuals face charges.