Teresa Lancaster Represents Survivors in Archdiocese Bankruptcy Hearing

Teresa Lancaster was 14 when the Rev. Joseph Maskell first raped her in his office at Archbishop Keough High School, beginning a nightmare that would derail her life and, decades later, help force the Archdiocese of Baltimore into bankruptcy court for a hearing that starts Thursday.

Attorneys for both sides say they hope it produces a settlement for more than 900 abuse claims frozen when the archdiocese filed for Chapter 11 protection on Sept. 29, 2023 — two days before Maryland’s Child Victims Act eliminated the statute of limitations for civil suits, The Banner reported.

“All the guns were fired at once,” Lancaster said. “It was ‘The Keepers.’ It was the attorney general’s report, and people reading hundreds of pages of what these children went through, finally. … And instead of saying, ‘Oh, they were abused,’ they heard the words. They were raped anally, orally, bloodily. Let’s hear the dirty words because that’s what was suffered.”

Lancaster, now an attorney representing three dozen survivors, was the second former Keough student to sue the archdiocese in 1994, filing as Jane Roe alongside Jean Wehner, Jane Doe. A judge dismissed it, and Lancaster accepted a $40,000 settlement that released the archdiocese from future claims tied to Maskell. She vowed the church had not seen the last of her.

The long road to the bar

At 48, Lancaster enrolled at the University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law, earning her juris doctor with honors and a health-law certificate in 2002, according to her professional biography.

She joined the Suder Law Firm to represent survivors, mostly pro bono, and became a central figure in “The Keepers,” the Netflix documentary that examined Maskell’s abuse and the unsolved 1969 murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik, who was reportedly preparing to report him.

She also lobbied the General Assembly for a decade alongside Del. C.T. Wilson, a Charles County Democrat and abuse survivor himself, to pass the Child Victims Act. “By speaking up, as Lancaster has, you forgo your greatest desire, which is to have a normal life, to become a poster child for the worst thing that has ever happened in your life,” Wilson said.

Bankruptcy freezes the docket

The archdiocese’s bankruptcy filing halted the surge of cases the new law unleashed. Survivors’ attorneys say insurance proceeds could push a global settlement above $100 million, but they insist on binding child-protection safeguards as a condition.

“The archdiocese acknowledges the abuse Teresa Lancaster suffered as a child at the hands of one of its priests and the lasting pain that abuse has caused,” spokesperson Christian Kendzierski said in an email. “We are deeply sorry for the harm she experienced.”

A paper trail of complicity

The 2023 Maryland Attorney General’s report, which Lancaster helped pressure the state to release, documented abuse of 600 children by 156 clergy since the 1940s.

It revealed that Maskell was moved from two parishes in the 1960s after reports of “troubling behavior with children, including a fascination with the sexual fantasies and behavior of boy scouts and ‘having young girls in the rectory under suspicious circumstances,'” the report says. In 1975 he was shifted to an administrative post. He died in 2000 with at least 39 known victims.

After the 2002 Boston Globe investigation sparked a national reckoning, the Baltimore Archdiocese issued a report naming a few dozen abusive priests. But the attorney general found that candor did not last: “The incontrovertible history uncovered by this investigation is one of pervasive and persistent abuse by priests and other Archdiocese personnel. It is also a history of repeated dismissal or cover up of that abuse by the Catholic Church hierarchy.”

The advocate in the room

“Teresa was the face of the abuse, a recognizable face, and had a story she was bravely able to share,” Schindler said. “There was enormous value in her being able to do that, to expose it, and to never let up.”

Researcher Annie Copeland said Lancaster still takes weekly calls from distraught clients. Survivors’ committee lead Paul Jan Zdunek called her “a great voice of reason” who has attended every hearing and helped bridge the gap between confidential negotiations and the broader survivor network.

Today she is primary caregiver for her second husband, Randy, who has Alzheimer’s and coronary artery disease. “For her to navigate everything that she went through and then go to school and become a lawyer, because she was like, ‘Oh, I’m just gonna fix this myself, if no one’s gonna do anything about it?’ that’s pretty extraordinary,” John Benam said.

The Archdiocese of Baltimore, founded in 1789 as the nation’s first Catholic diocese, spans the city and nine Maryland counties including Anne Arundel, where Lancaster lives and where Archbishop Keough High School once stood. As of 2020 it served an estimated 525,000 Catholics through 139 parishes and two major seminaries, St. Mary’s Seminary and University in Baltimore and Mount St. Mary’s Seminary in Emmitsburg.

The girl who once played judge on the family piano bench finds peace now at the river behind her Annapolis home, hugging her children and watching her cat stretch on the piano. Whatever happens Thursday will not be the end. When her phone rings, she will take the call.