Texas Eighth Graders Fall Two Grade Levels Behind in Math as State Board Begins Standards Rewrite

“Texas education policy in that period was defined by rigorous standards, consistent measurement, and consequences tied to results,” the Texas 2036 report states.

The State Board of Education took a preliminary vote Tuesday to approve a timeline for overhauling the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills for mathematics, with the rewrite expected to begin next year after newly elected members take office.

From 2011 to 2024, Texas eighth graders lost 21 points on the National Assessment of Educational Progress, meaning a typical eighth grader in 2024 performed about two grade levels behind a typical eighth grader in 2011, according to the report released Tuesday by the Dallas-based public policy group Texas 2036.

The decline coincides with the state setting aside rigorous accountability policies toward the end of the first decade of the 2000s, the report notes. Between 1990 and 2011, Texas eighth grade math scores grew by 32 points — about three grade levels of learning — while the national public school average climbed just 21 points.

The board’s Ad Hoc Committee on Mathematics Instruction Framework, chaired by member L.J. Francis, R-Corpus Christi, found that teachers, parents and other stakeholders said the current standards require teachers to cover too many concepts.

They asked the board to pare down the number of required standards while maintaining the overall level of rigor. Francis said the committee also reviewed other high-performing educational systems, which in many cases introduce concepts such as decimals, integer operations and grouping symbols in later grades than Texas does.

Texas Eighth Graders Fall Two Grade Levels Behind in Math as State Board Begins Standards Rewrite
Photo: yahoo.com

The board appears poised to flip to Democratic control in January, with seven Democrats and seven Republicans taking seats. In the race for District 8, which covers suburban Houston and southeast Texas, Democrat Dana Van de Walker leads Republican incumbent Audrey Young by fewer than 600 votes. Young has not said whether she plans to request a recount.

The Texas 2036 report highlights that middle school math skills are a requirement for many jobs in the trades. Electricians, carpenters and HVAC technicians all use concepts such as one-variable equations, the Pythagorean theorem, slope and proportional reasoning — all skills that appear in Texas middle school standards. The state has not seen the same declines in math among fourth graders.

San Antonio ISD’s 2026 academic-growth report counted 14,719 mathematics tests evaluated, giving families a local measure to follow as the state reviews its standards, according to Bexar Report. Texas mathematics standards were last amended effective Sept. 12, 2012, according to the board’s agenda item.

Texas 2036 recommends updating the state’s math standards, sending math coaches to struggling schools and extending the Texas Education Agency’s new Parent Access to Supplemental Supports tutoring program to math. Currently, the program gives $400 for literacy tutoring to any student who did not pass the third grade STAAR reading test.

“I’ve heard from parents across the state who feel disconnected from what their kids are learning in school,” said Trip Davis, policy adviser for K-12 education at Texas 2036 and the report’s author.

“One good option could be a tool that gives guidance to parents of students who are struggling in math about how they can help — tips on helping them with their homework, ideas for incorporating math into their home life and information about outside tutoring.”

The proposed state timeline identifies June 2027 and June 2028 as milestones for the K–12 mathematics review and revision. The board is scheduled to reconvene Wednesday at 9 a.m.