Amy Bell surveyed 16 gluten-free BBQ potato chips for Tasting Table and found that most fell short of the flavor they promised, with two Whole Foods 365 varieties landing at the bottom of the ranking.
Bell, who recently returned to a gluten-free diet, wrote that the search for a safe BBQ chip revealed how often “natural flavors” conceal barley or wheat derivatives. She noted the FDA allows products labeled gluten-free to contain up to 20 parts per million of gluten, the threshold the National Celiac Association considers safe for people with celiac disease, but said third-party certification offers extra assurance for anyone highly sensitive.
The 365 Whole Foods Market organic barbecue flavored potato chips finished last. Bell wrote that neither she nor her tasting companion detected any BBQ character, describing the chip as tasting like cooking oil, nearly burnt potatoes and earthiness.
The non-organic 365 barbecue chips placed 15th; Bell said they lacked the burnt note but remained barely BBQ flavored, slightly bitter, and packaged in a bag that tore open while she was trying to open it.
Smash Kitchen’s kettle-cooked entries, both certified gluten-free and sold at Walmart, were undermined by what Bell identified as rancid sunflower oil flavor. The hot honey version, ranked 14th, delivered habanero heat that overwhelmed the BBQ profile, while the American style BBQ at 13th tasted predominantly of oil despite a later best-by date.

Lay’s Stax mesquite barbecue crisps came in 12th. Bell’s tasting companion threw the chip in the trash after one bite. The product carries a gluten-free label without certification and includes corn flour, potato starch and rice flour; Bell said the texture and powdery residue mimicked a failed attempt at Pringles.
Two chipotle-style chips missed the mark on smoke. Siete Chipotle BBQ, certified gluten-free and found at Walmart, led with chipotle chile and red chile powder but offered none of the smokiness Bell expects from either chipotle or BBQ.
Clancy’s avocado oil chipotle BBQ kettle chips from Aldi, labeled gluten-free without certification, read more like a salt-and-vinegar chip with heat; Bell’s companion ranked it third for personal preference, but Bell kept it at 10th because it did not taste like BBQ.
Clancy’s kettle chips mesquite barbecue, also from Aldi, placed ninth. The bag lists no malted barley powder, though the online ingredient list includes it, and the chips carry a gluten-free claim without certification. Bell found mesquite smoke and bitterness dominated a harder-than-average kettle texture.
Snackish BBQ Bash potato crisps, certified gluten-free and sold at Target, divided the panel. Bell’s companion ranked them second; Bell placed them eighth, calling them a “delicious little weirdo” with a tangy flavor explosion, 8 grams of protein, added cassava fiber and a powdery mouthfeel from the dried-potato, potato-protein and rice-protein base.
Kettle Brand air fried Texas BBQ chips reached seventh. Certified gluten-free with 30 percent less fat than the brand’s regular chip, they delivered cayenne-driven cheek-encircling heat and a molasses-tinged aftertaste Bell found distinctive but outside the mainstream BBQ profile.
Lay’s baked not fried barbecue chips rounded out the bottom half at sixth. Labeled gluten-free without certification, they came closer to Bell’s mental model of BBQ flavor despite a reputation as a low-ranked store-bought chip in other comparisons.
Bell’s write-up continues through the top five, but the provided material ends at the sixth-place entry. The pattern so far shows that certification, oil freshness and whether the seasoning actually reads as barbecue — rather than chipotle, vinegar or burnt potato — separate the contenders from the also-rans.