Thieves Hit Two Priuses on Milwaukee’s East Side Monday

Catalytic converter thieves hit at least two Toyota Priuses on Milwaukee’s east side Monday, leaving drivers facing four-figure repair bills and at least one resident questioning whether to leave the neighborhood entirely.

Stacey Gehrke and Dalia Aboukabchat each discovered the thefts when they started their cars Monday morning and heard the signature roar of an exposed exhaust pipe, TMJ4 News reported. Gehrke heard the noise from inside her home when her fiancé turned the key.

“I heard this really loud noise, and all I thought was, ‘oh god I hope that’s not our car,'” she told the station. Aboukabchat described a similar moment when she tried to drive. “When I started my car, it was like a loud roaring,” Aboukabchat said.

Thieves Hit Two Priuses on Milwaukee's East Side Monday

Both women posted on the Nextdoor app and quickly realized they were not alone. “I shouldn’t be surprised, but I was surprised at how many different Priuses had their catalytic converters stolen,” Gehrke said. A mechanic at the shop repairing Gehrke’s car said thieves target the hybrid models because their converters contain a higher concentration of precious metals — platinum, palladium and rhodium — making them more valuable on the scrap market.

Gehrke estimated her repair at roughly $1,600. “I have a certain budget, and I didn’t expect to be paying more than I would this week,” Aboukabchat told TMJ4 News. Both women will be without their vehicles while repairs are completed; Gehrke said she might take a scooter to work tomorrow. “Maybe I’m just going to have to get more protection, more cameras, higher security,” Aboukabchat said.

Catalytic converter thefts are costing some Milwaukee Toyota Prius drivers — TMJ4 News

For Gehrke, the theft marks a breaking point. “Which is a bummer, because we really like it down here on the east side. It’s a beautiful area, it’s a beautiful neighborhood, but the crime has really gone up, and what you pay in taxes down here and with the crime, it’s not worth it anymore,” she said.

Gehrke called the theft the “final breaking point” that has her considering moving out of Milwaukee.

Milwaukee police had no information to share regarding Gehrke’s case. For Aboukabchat’s vehicle, the department confirmed it is seeking an unknown suspect or suspects and that the investigation remains ongoing. Each woman reported the theft to Milwaukee police.