Chow Shuffles Council, Appoints Erskine-Smith to Housing, Layton to Infrastructure

Toronto’s new council term opened Thursday with a leadership shuffle that concentrates power in a handful of deputies and installs two former federal Liberals to spearhead the city’s most combustible files: housing and transit.

Mayor Olivia Chow appointed former Beaches–East York MP Nate Erskine-Smith to chair the Planning and Housing Committee and returning University–Rosedale councillor Mike Layton to lead Infrastructure and Environment, the Toronto Star reported. Paul Ainslie, a Chow deputy, takes over the TTC board chair from defeated incumbent Jamaal Myers, CityNews confirmed.

The moves come as the city stares down a $1.1-billion budget hole and the expiry of the Ontario–Toronto New Deal that papered over last year’s shortfall. Premier Doug Ford has already ruled out renewing that agreement, leaving Chow to close the gap while holding property-tax hikes near inflation, freezing transit fares for a fourth year and expanding the school-lunch program.

“Wasting taxpayer money was not the mandate that Mr. Ford was given.”

Mike Layton, Infrastructure and Environment Chair

Layton, who served 12 years on council before a four-year hiatus, framed his mandate partly as a defence of the bike-lane network against provincial legislation that would force the city to remove lanes on major arterial roads. His appointment signals Chow intends to defend the city’s bike lane network from the province’s overhaul.

Chow Shuffles Council, Appoints Erskine-Smith to Housing, Layton to Infrastructure
Photo: The Globe and Mail

Erskine-Smith, elected last month after a failed Ontario Liberal leadership bid, inherits the housing file from Gord Perks, who retired. The Globe and Mail noted he will share the vice-chair role with Diana Chan McNally, a former housing worker and advocate The Globe and Mail reported.

Chow also declined her designated seat on the Toronto Police Services Board for a second consecutive term, a decision rival Brad Bradford attacked during the mayoral campaign as an abdication of civilian oversight. “Community safety is job number one of local government,” Bradford said in July. “When the biggest decisions about policing in this city get made, the mayor isn’t in the room.”

Toronto Life reported the mayor informed the clerk by letter Thursday, clearing the way for rookie Toronto Centre Coun. Curran Stikuts to join returning members Shelley Carroll and Amber Morley on a board currently navigating the fallout from Project South, a corruption investigation implicating officers in bribery, illegal searches and a murder plot.

The police budget hit $1.43 billion under Chow’s first term, and festival organizers have warned that rising policing costs threaten the viability of street events. Carroll, reprised as budget chief, acknowledged the fiscal squeeze Thursday: “Other big cities have been able to deal with homelessness better than we have and there’s a lot of lessons that need to be learned there.”

Chow Shuffles Council, Appoints Erskine-Smith to Housing, Layton to Infrastructure
Photo: CityNews Toronto

Ausma Malik, elected Speaker Wednesday after 16 years of Frances Nunziata, was reappointed as primary deputy mayor — effectively giving her procedural control of council and executive liaison duties simultaneously. The Toronto Sun described the dual role as “just about all the power she can” hold.

Malik told the chamber Wednesday, “Fairness is the heart of my politics — from working with many of you, you know that — and fairness is the heart of progressive politics that are also mine.”

The Striking Committee filled out the remaining board slots Thursday afternoon. Amber Morley returns to the police board and adds Economic Development and Culture vice-chair duties. Alejandra Bravo (Davenport) and Neethan Shan (Scarborough–Rouge River) join Ainslie and Layton on the TTC board. Josh Matlow (Toronto–St. Paul’s), Ausma Malik (Spadina–Fort York) and Vincent Crisanti (Etobicoke North) were appointed to the Infrastructure and Environment Committee by council vote.

Olivia Chow, born in British Hong Kong in 1957, arrived in Toronto at 13 and began public life as a school-board trustee in 1985 before serving on Metro Toronto Council from 1991 to 1998 and on the amalgamated city council until 2005.

She then represented Trinity—Spadina as a federal NDP MP from 2006 to 2014, resigning to run for mayor that year and placing third. Chow was elected Toronto’s 66th mayor in 2023, becoming the first Chinese-Canadian to hold the office and the first woman to serve as mayor since amalgamation.

Chow has promised a “financial solution that is fair, predictable, and grows with the economy,” but the province’s refusal to renew the New Deal removes the single largest plug in last year’s leak.