Variety’s 100 Greatest Movie Stars List Sparks Debate Over Rankings and Omissions

Variety published a ranked list of the 100 “Greatest” movie stars of all time, prompting immediate debate over the methodology, specific placements, and notable omissions.

The list defines a “movie star” as distinct from a great actor, describing the concept as a “magic zone where talent and luminescence fuse” to find “stars who magnetize us, the ones who awe and overpower us and make us swoon,” according to the publication’s article.

The top ten features Marilyn Monroe at No. 1, followed by Humphrey Bogart, Charlie Chaplin, Jack Nicholson, Katharine Hepburn, Sidney Poitier, Marlon Brando, Tom Cruise, Toshiro Mifune, and Barbra Streisand. The A.V. Club noted the list is an “absurd result to an absurd exercise,” highlighting the granular arguments such rankings provoke, such as the placement of Matt Damon and Jack Lemmon at positions 71 and 70, respectively, significantly ahead of Philip Seymour Hoffman, Lillian Gish, or Divine.

The outlet also observed that Ben Affleck did not appear on the list at all, calling it “a continuing data point in how we, as a society, get a little kick out of treating him just a smidge worse than we treat Damon.”

JoBlo identified several low rankings and high-profile absences. Sylvester Stallone appears at No. 99, while Eddie Murphy ranks No. 96, placed below Timothée Chalamet at No. 86 and Divine at No. 79.

Actors entirely missing from the list include Bruce Willis, Jackie Chan, Mel Gibson, Johnny Depp, Omar Sharif, Michelle Yeoh, Peter O’Toole, Charlton Heston, Gene Hackman, Jim Carrey, Doris Day, and Samuel L. Jackson. Variety’s article does not explicitly address the criteria for why certain actors were excluded.

Variety magazine publishes top 100 movie stars of all time list — Sunrise

Demographically, the A.V. Club observed that nobody born this century made the cut, while the youngest person in the Top 10, Tom Cruise, is 64. Nicolas Cage’s placement at No. 89 also drew specific scrutiny.