Three Minnesota Photojournalists Sue St. Paul Police Over Chemical Munitions During ICE Raid

Three Minnesota photojournalists have filed a federal lawsuit against the St. Paul Police Department, alleging officers targeted them with pepper balls, close-range pepper spray and tear gas while they were clearly identified as press during an immigration raid last November.

The complaint, filed Tuesday in U.S. District Court, names Police Chief Axel Henry and twelve unnamed officers as defendants. Attorneys for the journalists argue the force violated their First, Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights and amounted to assault and battery.

“The use of this tear gas, like the use of the pepper balls, was clearly meant as retaliation for plaintiffs’ exercise of their First Amendment rights,” attorney Kevin Riach wrote in the filing. “The officers could not have been shooting at anyone other than Nesheim, Yücel and Evans, who were all clustered within several feet of one another.”

The raid and the response

On Nov. 25, 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents attempted to arrest a man in the Payne-Phalen neighborhood. He fled into his home on Rose Avenue East. A crowd of protesters gathered outside as ICE worked to detain him.

Police officers in protective gear deploy chemical munitions
Photo: mprnews.org

Sahan Journal’s Aaron Nesheim, MPR News photojournalist Kerem Yücel and freelancer Timothy Evans arrived with press passes visible and professional cameras in hand. Evans wore a ballistic vest marked “PRESS.” They positioned themselves at least ten feet from the nearest protesters, off to the side of the crowd and out of the police line of advance, according to the complaint.

After ICE left with the detainees, protesters shouted at the remaining St. Paul officers to leave. As officers withdrew, they deployed chemical munitions toward the crowd — and directly at the three journalists standing apart from it.

Yücel sprayed at close range, hit with pepper balls

The complaint details a sustained assault on Yücel. An officer identified as John Doe 1 pepper-sprayed a protester; the cloud hit Yücel. That same officer then pointed the canister directly at him.

Federal raid in St. Paul sparks protest [RAW VIDEO] — FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul

Minutes later, a second officer sprayed Yücel in the face from close range without warning. He continued shooting. A third officer sprayed him again. Then an officer identified as John Doe 5 “aimed his weapon and fired pepper balls directly at Yücel’s chest, shoulders, and throat,” the complaint alleges.

“At no time did (Yücel) demonstrate any conduct that would have suggested he was a protester, let alone engage in any hostile or threatening conduct towards law enforcement,” the filing says.

Yücel inhaled and swallowed the chemicals. He struggled to breathe and was taken by ambulance to Regions Hospital. Staff there could not admit him to the main facility because the irritants on his body and clothing posed a risk to staff and other patients. EMTs placed his jacket in a garbage bag to contain the contamination.

Three Minnesota Photojournalists Sue St. Paul Police Over Chemical Munitions During ICE Raid
Photo: yahoo.com

Journalists Injured by Police Projectiles

Evans suffered severe abdominal bruising after a pepper ball exploded inside his ballistic vest. The bruising lasted about a month. A police projectile struck Nesheim in the head. All three journalists experienced chemical effects on their eyes and airways, and all three sought mental health treatment in the weeks that followed.

The plaintiffs say police never ordered them to disperse or move away.

“Journalists and freedom of the press play an essential role in our democracy, and it is imperative that we protect journalists from harm.”

MPR President Duchesne Drew said in a statement Thursday.

Internal Affairs Review Remains Ongoing

The St. Paul Police Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission is still investigating the incident. A department spokesperson declined to comment on the pending litigation.

The lawsuit seeks damages, attorney’s fees and an injunction barring the department from further unconstitutional conduct against the journalists.

Court Will Decide Constitutional Boundary

The case has been assigned to U.S. District Court in Minnesota. Discovery will likely focus on body-camera footage, command communications and the department’s training protocols for interactions with credentialed media during civil unrest. The Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission’s findings, when released, could shape the city’s liability.

For now, the three photographers wait. Their cameras captured the raid. Their bodies absorbed the response. The courts will decide whether the Constitution drew a line that night on Rose Avenue — and whether anyone in uniform crossed it.