Connecticut Man Sentenced to 14 Months in Nationwide Fraud Conspiracy

Cirt Lindsay, 43, of Bridgeport, Connecticut, was sentenced on Monday to 14 months in federal prison for his role in a conspiracy that looted unclaimed property funds from state treasuries across the country.

Chief United States District Judge Christina Reiss imposed the sentence in Burlington, ordering Lindsay to serve three years of supervised release after his prison term and to forfeit $467,067.31, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Vermont. Restitution will be paid to unclaimed property agencies in Vermont, New York, Connecticut, Iowa, Georgia, South Dakota, and Minnesota.

Lindsay pleaded guilty on July 24 to conspiracy to commit mail fraud. Court records show he and two co-conspirators spent roughly three years manufacturing fake business entities designed to mimic the names of deceased individuals, defunct companies, or other rightful owners whose assets had drifted into state unclaimed property divisions.

“This scheme exploited a system designed to return lost money to its rightful owners,” said Jonathan A. Ophardt, First Assistant United States Attorney for the District of Vermont, in the department’s release. “Lindsay and his partners turned a public safeguard into a personal ATM.”

The operation was brazen in its mechanics. When state agencies issued checks to the fraudulent entities, Lindsay opened bank accounts in those names, deposited the checks, and moved the money out fast. He kept 20 to 30 percent of the proceeds for himself — cash withdrawals, mortgage payments, car payments, travel — while the rest flowed to his partners.

Conn. Man Gets 14 Months In Federal Prison For Stealing $470,000 From Vermont Treasury
Photo: caledonianrecord.com

In late 2021, the group targeted $467,067.31 held by the Vermont Unclaimed Property Department for an individual who had moved out of state. Lindsay opened an account in that person’s name with “LLC” appended, deposited the check, and the conspirators burned through nearly the entire sum within months, the U.S. Attorney’s Office reported.

Nationwide, the FBI estimated the trio initiated 19 fraudulent claims totaling $8.4 million. They successfully collected on $4.6 million of that, with Lindsay pocketing an estimated $600,000 over the three years he participated, the same release stated.

The case was prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorney Dana E. Hill. The FBI investigated.