A Minnehaha County grand jury has indicted Travis Morre on alternating counts of first-degree murder and first-degree manslaughter in the October shooting death of Derrick Franklin, adding the possibility of the death penalty to a case that began as a reported cardiac arrest.
The indictment, filed Thursday, layers the new charges on top of the original second-degree murder and aggravated assault counts filed by criminal complaint earlier this month, according to Sioux Falls Live. Morre, 45, is accused of killing Franklin, 48, on Oct. 10 in the 1000 block of East Eighth Street near Franklin Avenue.
First-degree murder carries a mandatory life sentence and opens the door to capital punishment in South Dakota. First-degree manslaughter, the alternating count, carries a maximum of life in prison but no mandatory minimum. Second-degree murder also mandates life without the possibility of the death penalty.
“The Sioux Falls Police Department has dedicated a substantial amount of time and resources to further this investigation in connection with community partners.”
German said in a statement following Morre’s arrest on Nov. 4.
The timeline from 911 call to arrest
The case did not start as a homicide investigation. At 8:30 p.m. on Oct. 10, dispatchers received a call for a cardiac arrest. Responders found Franklin unconscious, not breathing, with blood on him and a nearby vehicle. He was pronounced dead shortly after, and a preliminary autopsy ruled the death a homicide caused by two gunshot wounds.
For 25 days, police worked without a public suspect. On Nov. 4, officers arrested Morre near Eighth Street and Indiana Avenue on a warrant. Morre was scheduled to enter a plea Thursday, but court records show a continuance was granted. He is due back in court Dec. 18.
What the alternating charges mean
South Dakota law allows prosecutors to charge in the alternative when the evidence could support different degrees of culpability. A conviction on first-degree murder requires proof of premeditation. First-degree manslaughter applies when a killing occurs in the heat of passion or during the commission of certain felonies without the specific intent to kill.
Morre remains in custody. The Dec. 18 hearing will be his first opportunity to enter a plea to the indictment.