Planet Fitness to Open 4 New Long Island Gyms, Relocate 2

Planet Fitness is staking out nearly 108,400 square feet of new Long Island real estate, opening four clubs and moving two others to lock in what its broker calls superior locations before competitors can.

The expansion, detailed in a RIPCO Real Estate release and reported by Newsday, adds clubs in East Meadow, East Setauket, Lindenhurst and Valley Stream while relocating existing Centereach and Levittown gyms to larger, better-positioned spaces nearby.

Jack Chera, the RIPCO vice president who has represented the chain for about 15 years, told Newsday the moves are driven by expiring leases and a deliberate strategy to “beat the competition to the better space.” Planet Fitness did not respond to Newsday’s requests for comment.

The six leases reflect a broader tilt toward budget fitness. The Sports & Fitness Industry Association said budget gyms captured nearly 80 percent of U.S. health-club memberships last year, a 4.1 percent increase from 2024, while mid- and premium-priced clubs saw double-digit declines, according to data shared with Newsday.

“We just feel that these locations are superior,” said Chera in an interview, adding he had been working with Planet Fitness for about 15 years. “Their leases are up, and we just would rather beat the competition to the better space.”

Jack Chera, RIPCO Real Estate vice president, told Newsday

Six deals, one playbook

Each site meets the chain’s baseline: at least 15,000 square feet and a three-mile radius from any other Planet Fitness, Chera said. All six are corporately owned and anchored in shopping centers with ample parking.

In East Meadow, the company took the former Modell’s at 1900 Hempstead Turnpike — 16,912 square feet on the ground floor plus 5,000 square feet below — and plans to open before year end. Ken Breslin of Sabre Real Estate Group represented landlord Regency Centers.

Inline planet fitness exterior

East Setauket gets a 15,000-square-foot ground-level build-out at 4016 Nesconset Highway, currently occupied by La-Z-Boy. Construction starts in January; Chris Wierzbicki of Pliskin Realty handled the lease for landlord Jeff Port Partners.

Lindenhurst fills the 16,000-square-foot Blink Fitness box at 600 North Wellwood Avenue, targeting a January 2027 opening. Joanne Argenti of RIPCO represented landlord Lerner Properties.

Valley Stream’s 17,500-square-foot space at 225 West Merrick Road aims to open in December or January. Ed Gottlieb of Schuckman Realty represented Regency Centers.

Centereach relocates across the street from 81 Centereach Mall to a 19,000-square-foot former LA Fitness at 1934 Middle Country Road, sharing the building with a new Sprouts Farmers Market. Construction begins in January; landlord Basser-Kaufman was self-represented.

Levittown moves from 3025 Hempstead Turnpike to roughly 19,000 square feet at 3541 Hempstead Turnpike in Nassau Mall, formerly a Party City, with a May or June 2027 target. The Feil Organization was self-represented.

Context: a budget boom with 2,962 doors

As of September 30, Planet Fitness operated 2,962 corporate and franchised clubs systemwide, the company said in a November announcement. Third-quarter revenue reached $360 million, a 9 percent year-over-year increase.

Chera told LIBN the six Long Island leases reflect the company’s commitment to the market and noted his team has now handled 25 transactions for the chain here, with more in the pipeline.

“Long Island continues to be a strong market for Planet Fitness, and these six leases reflect the company’s commitment to growing here,” Chera told LIBN.

“Over the years, we’ve built a close working relationship with their team and a deep understanding of their business and expansion goals. That relationship, together with our knowledge of Long Island’s communities and real estate, allows us to help plan for their growth, recognize opportunities, and secure locations that support where they want to go next.”