Tallahassee Mayor Fires City Manager in First Act of New Commission

Tallahassee’s new mayor fired the city manager on Wednesday, the first act of a 3-2 commission majority elected November 3.

Jeremy Matlow, sworn in Monday, led the vote to oust Karen Jumonville, a 27-year city employee hired in June by the previous commission. The move came after Matlow and fellow progressives Jack Porter and P.J. Perez invalidated a contract clause requiring a 4-1 supermajority to fire her — a protection no prior manager held.

“We can’t move forward as a city with a city manager that doesn’t have a relationship with the mayor that’s based on trust and mutual respect,” Matlow said during the meeting. “And we just don’t have that right now.”

Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox and Curtis Richardson, who backed Jumonville’s hiring, voted no. Williams-Cox called the firing “cruel and unusual punishment” for staff facing the holidays. “We have employees who are worried about whether they’re going to be able to continue to have a livelihood through the end of the year,” she said.

Jumonville’s contract, approved in June, included the supermajority removal requirement. Matlow said he offered her a one-year probationary period with a simple-majority termination clause to “keep to the spirit of the city charter.” She declined.

“That did not build trust with me,” Matlow said.

Matlow said a “developer’s representative” told him before the selection process that then-City Manager Reese Goad was retiring and Jumonville was “pre-selected” to succeed him. Goad announced his retirement in April after nine years.

Monday’s reorganization meeting hinted at the shift. Curtis Richardson moved to appoint Jack Porter as mayor pro tempore — a role Porter never held despite serving since 2020. The title once rotated annually, but Porter frequently clashed with Dailey and Goad.

Now Richardson and Williams-Cox sit in the minority. They previously formed a 3-2 majority with former Mayor John Dailey, often outvoting Matlow and Porter.

Deputy City Attorney Lou Norvell was named interim manager Wednesday night.

Tallahassee, the state capital since 1824 and Leon County’s only incorporated municipality, was chosen as a legislative halfway point between Pensacola and St. Augustine after delegates endured weeks of perilous travel.

The city’s name, a Muskogean term often translated as “old fields,” reflects the cleared land Creek migrants found in the late 18th century. With a 2024 population of 205,089, it is the largest city in the Florida Panhandle and a college town whose student body exceeds 70,000 across three institutions.

“It’s Thanksgiving and Christmas season. We have employees who are worried about whether they’re going to be able to continue to have a livelihood through the end of the year. It’s cruel and unusual punishment for people who’ve dedicated their lives to the city of Tallahassee.”

— Dianne Williams-Cox, City Commissioner

The commission meets again next week to discuss the fire-services agreement with Leon County, another item on the new majority’s agenda.