West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt and four of his office employees are facing federal charges following a grand jury indictment that alleges a pattern of theft, fraud, and systematic abuse of public office.
The indictment, announced Monday, targets a core agency responsible for keeping the state’s financial integrity in check.
According to a news release from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of West Virginia, the 66-year-old auditor is accused of orchestrating a scheme to acquire multiple properties by improperly issuing tax deeds. The federal grand jury returned 10 counts against Hunt, including nine counts of theft of property and one count of bank fraud.
The reach of the investigation extends deep into the auditor’s office. Prosecutors named three other Charleston residents—David Keith Cole, 57; Frederic Scott Caudill, 59; and Robert Lisle Johns, 66—all of whom held positions within the office.
They are each accused of nine counts of theft of property. The filing alleges that Hunt overruled career state employees to facilitate the transfer of nine properties in Kanawha and Boone counties to Johns, who had been hired as special counsel in June of last year.
“These are serious allegations, particularly because they involve the office entrusted with overseeing the finances of the state of West Virginia,” said U.S. Attorney Moore Capito during a news conference on Monday.
The charges also involve allegations of payroll fraud. Marie Ann Hoffman, 66, of Hurricane, is accused of submitting fraudulent timecards that included hours she supposedly worked at Hunt’s private law firm. The indictment alleges that Cole, the auditor’s deputy chief of staff, validated these timecards with Hunt’s knowledge, essentially allowing state employees to work on private firm business during state hours.
Hunt, a Republican who won his seat in 2024 after defeating long-time office veteran Mary Ann Roebuck Claytor, has publicly denied the charges. “I am innocent of these charges. This indictment is an insult to the principles on which this country was founded,” Hunt said in a statement issued Monday. He added that he intends to remain in his post while the legal process unfolds.
The political fallout was immediate. Leaders from across the spectrum have called for the auditor’s resignation, citing the essential nature of his office in maintaining public trust. West Virginia House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, a Republican, said that while the presumption of innocence is a fundamental right, the public is entitled to leadership that is free from such accusations.
“Auditor Hunt should immediately resign from his office. If he resolves to do otherwise, the House of Delegates will take swift action in January to restore integrity to the Office of the West Virginia State Auditor,” Hanshaw said.
The Democratic side of the aisle echoed these sentiments. “The West Virginia State Auditor’s job is to investigate waste, fraud and abuse across state agencies—not to be the creator of waste, fraud and abuse,” said West Virginia Democratic Party Chair Mike Pushkin. He further said that keeping the current staff in place would be akin to leaving the “fox in charge of the henhouse.”
State Treasurer Larry Pack, also a Republican, joined the call for resignation, emphasizing that the charges cast a shadow over the state’s efforts to maintain transparency. “West Virginians deserve a government that is fully transparent, accountable and works for the betterment of our state,” Pack said.
The situation creates a precarious scenario for the state auditor’s office. Tasked with auditing county governments, municipalities, and boards of education, the agency is meant to be the primary defense against the very types of financial misconduct alleged in the federal indictment.
When the office itself becomes the subject of a criminal investigation, it complicates the state’s ability to ensure that taxpayer funding is being allocated appropriately at the local level.
As the legal proceedings move into the court system, the focus remains on the upcoming legislative session. As the House of Delegates prepares to intervene in January, the future of the auditor’s office and Mark Hunt’s tenure face opposition from state leadership.