Brewers Validated: Letting Dustin May Walk to White Sox Was Smart Business

The Milwaukee Brewers watched their World Series starter sign a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday, a price tag that validates the front office’s decision to let Dustin May walk rather than exercise his mutual option for 2027.

Milwaukee acquired May from St. Louis at the July deadline, surrendering two elite prospects for the right-hander and reliever JoJo Romero. The plan was straightforward: Romero would stabilize the bullpen, and May would eat innings down the stretch. He made ten starts and threw 36 2/3 innings, but the results were jarring — a 5.65 ERA and a 2.53 strikeout-to-walk ratio, averaging barely three innings per outing, Milwaukee Brewers On SI reported.

The St. Louis contrast

Those numbers stand in sharp relief to what May did in a Cardinals uniform. Across 21 starts and 109 innings before the trade, he posted a 4.38 ERA with a 3.03 strikeout-to-walk ratio and worked just over five innings per start. The velocity and stuff that made him a former top prospect never translated to Milwaukee, and the postseason offered no redemption — a 5.73 ERA in five appearances.

Dustin May signing with White Sox after winning World Series with Milwaukee Brewers — MLB News

Market values ceiling over recent track record

Chicago is betting on the 29-year-old’s ceiling, not his 2026 track record. Even his 2025 season — a 4.90 ERA in 25 appearances — didn’t scare off a market that pushed his average annual value above $17 million. That figure would have slotted as the second-highest salary on Milwaukee’s 2027 books, ahead of World Series MVP William Contreras, for a pitcher projected as a fourth or fifth starter.

Prospect cost already paid

The Brewers absorbed the prospect cost in July; the only remaining variable was the 2027 option. May declined it quickly after the championship, and Milwaukee never re-engaged.

Brewers Validated: Letting Dustin May Walk to White Sox Was Smart Business
Photo: sports.yahoo.com